Sceptics beliefs ?

[Venturi Swirl]

All I ask is equal treatment. If I don't provide a cite my post is deleted. The same rule should apply to others who don't provide cites.

I’ve asked for numerous cites and simply been ignored.  I got over it. 

[Eleanor]

All I ask is equal treatment. If I don't provide a cite my post is deleted. The same rule should apply to others who don't provide cites.

Not by any Moderator that I have seen.

[Mr Gray]

I’ve asked for numerous cites and simply been ignored.  I got over it.

Me too..

[G-Unit]

Not by any Moderator that I have seen.

It happens;

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10544.msg511027#msg511027

[Eleanor]

It happens;

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10544.msg511027#msg511027

That was in January.  Good heavens.  I've had more comments deleted than you have.

[G-Unit]

That was in January.  Good heavens.  I've had more comments deleted than you have.

I didn't even know it had happened myself until I was given a link to that discussion as what seemed to be some kind of justification for the lack of a cite in the latest incident. In my opinion you can't demand cites from others if you refuse to supply them yourself.

[Eleanor]

I didn't even know it had happened myself until I was given a link to that discussion as what seemed to be some kind of justification for the lack of a cite in the latest incident. In my opinion you can't demand cites from others if you refuse to supply them yourself.

It has to depend on the discussion itself.  Cites are being demanded in the most ridiculous cases sometimes.

[ShiningInLuz]

It has to depend on the discussion itself.  Cites are being demanded in the most ridiculous cases sometimes.

Seconded.   

[G-Unit]

It has to depend on the discussion itself.  Cites are being demanded in the most ridiculous cases sometimes.

I think it's fairly simple. Statements of fact need cites. Statements of opinion don't. 

[jassi]

The problem arises when opinion is passed off as fact.

[Mr Gray]

I think it's fairly simple. Statements of fact need cites. Statements of opinion don't.

I have provided a cite to support Brietta stating how important accurate witness statements are stressed in police training... It would be odd if SY didn't realize this... We can't prove the mccanns have been reinterviewed but it would be very odd if they haven't...

[G-Unit]

I have provided a cite to support Brietta stating how important accurate witness statements are stressed in police training... It would be odd if SY didn't realize this... We can't prove the mccanns have been reinterviewed but it would be very odd if they haven't...

Operation Grange may indeed have asked questions of those involved. Reinterviewing witnesses would make sense whoever interviewed them originally. You may believe OG did those things, but as you admit you can't prove it, it remains opinion.  One thing we do know is that both the McCanns and Op Grange paid to have the PJ files translated, so they certainly weren't dismissing the contents.

[jassi]

It would be fascinated to know if these translations differed significantly from those we have seen on line.

[G-Unit]

It would be fascinated to know if these translations differed significantly from those we have seen on line.

Even the most talented translator can't translate 'entered using the key, the door beiing locked' as 'entered via the unlocked patio door'

[Mr Gray]

Even the most talented translator can't translate 'entered using the key, the door beiing locked' as 'entered via the unlocked patio door'

Its not verbatim... I think the translator may have used some artistic licence... You can claim what you want... Due to the, way the accounts, were taken nothing can be confirmed either way