Amaral and the dogs

[Alice Purjorick]

In my opinion it does, and as we know all opinions are equally valid.

That sounds fair enough to me; so you play to your opinion and I'll play to mine.

[ferryman]

You mean the FSS sent a report saying:
Nil.

Zilch

Blank.

Odd that.

The FSS had as much clue about what might have happened to Madeleine after processing material forwarded to the laboratory as they had before: that is, none.

[Jean-Pierre]

What was the DNA taken from?

I thought you were well informed about the background to the case.

here is the FSS report.

Enjoy (if that's the right word?)

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id268.html

[Alice Purjorick]

The FSS had as much clue about what might have happened to Madeleine after processing material forwarded to the laboratory as they had before: that is, none.

So by that token they could neither rule anything in nor rule anything out.

[ferryman]

So by that token they could neither rule anything in nor rule anything out.

They could rule nothing in.

They could rule out that anything they analysed progressed the investigation.

Nothing did.

[Mr Gray]

So by that token they could neither rule anything in nor rule anything out.

so maddie could have been abducted by aliens

[Mr Gray]

What was the DNA taken from?

unless it is confirmed that the dna was taken from a dead person then it was not from human remains

[Alice Purjorick]

unless it is confirmed that the dna was taken from a dead person then it was not from human remains

So?

[Mr Gray]

So?

then Stephen is wrong to say human remains were found

[Alice Purjorick]

I thought you were well informed about the background to the case.

here is the FSS report.

Enjoy (if that's the right word?)

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id268.html

I do not believe I ever said that. I just get p****d off with people playing duck and drakes with reports we have all read, by quoting from the body not the conclusions and making inane comments like "I understand it better than you my dad works in the court/police station/hospital/laboratory (delete as necessary)so I should know". So asking questions is always good for a laugh if somewhat like pulling teeth.

[Alfred R Jones]

I do not believe I ever said that. I just get p****d off with people playing duck and drakes with reports we have all read, by quoting from the body not the conclusions and making inane comments like "I understand it better than you my dad works in the court/police station/hospital/laboratory (delete as necessary)so I should know". So asking questions is always good for a laugh if somewhat like pulling teeth.

What's your opinion of those who quote from the Interim Report to try and make a case for the McCanns' guilt?

[Alice Purjorick]

What's your opinion of those who quote from the Interim Report to try and make a case for the McCanns' guilt?

Pretty much the same old stick. Likely to come up with the wrong or right answer by accident rather than design if all the info is not available.

This is Lowes conclusion btw:
Conclusion
In my opinion, the laboratory results that were attained did not help to clarify whether or not the DNA results obtained within the scope of this case were from Madeleine McCann.
Now that is not too hard to understand is it.

[Alice Purjorick]

then Stephen is wrong to say human remains were found

So?

[Mr Gray]

Pretty much the same old stick. Likely to come up with the wrong or right answer by accident rather than design if all the info is not available.

This is Lowes conclusion btw:
Conclusion
In my opinion, the laboratory results that were attained did not help to clarify whether or not the DNA results obtained within the scope of this case were from Madeleine McCann.
Now that is not too hard to understand is it.

It's easy to understand but as usual posters put different interpretations on it

[Mr Gray]

So?

so it looks like you've given up trying to defend his absurd claim