Sceptics beliefs ?

[kizzy]

Why stage an abduction by opening a window and shutter claiming it was jemmied and then not actually jemmy it and then closing it?

Wasnt it the blowing curtains/slamming door - that alerted kmc to look in the bedroom.

Something had to attract her attention - or how else would she have known Maddie had gone. 

[kizzy]

Only the patio door was left open & no one went in or out of it without tidying up after themselves.
The front door was locked, the fairytale abductor required a key to enter it.

Or maybe the window would have been jemmied- but backfired in the time scale and obvious panic.

Maybe not - no fingerprints were found only kmcs

[Venturi Swirl]

Wasnt it the blowing curtains/slamming door - that alerted kmc to look in the bedroom.

Something had to attract her attention - or how else would she have known Maddie had gone. 

Ooh,now let’s see, she could have claimed one of the twins cried out in their sleep or she went in to make sure they were all covered up with blankets, don’t you think? 

[kizzy]

Ooh,now let’s see, she could have claimed one of the twins cried out in their sleep or she went in to make sure they were all covered up with blankets, don’t you think? 

What - wouldn't she have had to wake one of them up if that was the case.

That wouldn't have been easy -  would it.

Make sure they where all covered up with blankets - no I don't think. 

[G-Unit]

Ooh,now let’s see, she could have claimed one of the twins cried out in their sleep or she went in to make sure they were all covered up with blankets, don’t you think? 

That wouldn't have allowed her to deduce abduction immediately.

[Venturi Swirl]

That wouldn't have allowed her to deduce abduction immediately.

It would if she’d claimed she looked at Madeleine’s bed and there was no Madeleine.

[Venturi Swirl]

What - wouldn't she have had to wake one of them up if that was the case.

That wouldn't have been easy -  would it.

Make sure they where all covered up with blankets - no I don't think. 

Zero logic in you post IMO.  Are you a parent?  Are you not familiar with the idea of making sure your young children are covered up at night?   

[Lace]

Why use the window at all - if there had been someone observing them as they say on previous nights.

They would have seen that the doors were left open.

They would also have seen many people up and down the patio area.   The front door was more secluded.    It could be the person got in through the window and handed Madeleine out to another person,  or came in through the window and went out through the door,  or just opened the window once inside to hand Madeleine out through it,  or to get suspicion away from the fact they had a key,  or just as a quick getaway if caught in the room.

[Venturi Swirl]

They would also have seen many people up and down the patio area.   The front door was more secluded.    It could be the person got in through the window and handed Madeleine out to another person,  or came in through the window and went out through the door,  or just opened the window once inside to hand Madeleine out through it,  or to get suspicion away from the fact they had a key,  or just as a quick getaway if caught in the room.

The latter is the most plausible explanation in my view.  Makes total sense.

[G-Unit]

It would if she’d claimed she looked at Madeleine’s bed and there was no Madeleine.

Would she have known immediately that Madeleome had been taken? Not accordinf to her. Har first thought was that Madeleine was in her parent's bed. It was the opin window and shutters that told her what had happened.

[Lace]

Only the patio door was left open & no one went in or out of it without tidying up after themselves.
The front door was locked, the fairytale abductor required a key to enter it.

Can you explain how the person who entered apartments to get into bed with children actually entered the apartments?

[pathfinder73]

Gerry found that the shutter could be raised from outside,   was it supposed to do that?   If the shutter was onlly supposed to be raised by using the control in the bedroom then,  yes it was broken.   Gerry by the sound of it was very upset 'roaring like a bull'  it was said,  so maybe he did say it was broken or levered up.   How can anyone suggest that he was lying about it?

Who actually saw him raise the shutters? DP entered the apartment after the alarm and never saw it. Read his rog. And more importantly, why would Kate ask DW to try and raise them which she was unable to do if Gerry had already done so?

[Venturi Swirl]

Would she have known immediately that Madeleome had been taken? Not accordinf to her. Har first thought was that Madeleine was in her parent's bed. It was the opin window and shutters that told her what had happened.

Why does thr “immediately “ factor matter in this scenario?  After checking the apartment she would have been able to conclude (remember in this scenario she s alleging an abduction) that Madeleine must have been taken.  It’s really tiresome to have to keep pointing out the obvious. 

[Angelo222]

If the window was shut and it is later found open it has been tampered with IMO.

People forget that pushing up the shutter doesn't allow access to the bedroom if the window is closed and secured.  The only way an intruder could get into that bedroom via the window was if the window was open to begin with.

[kizzy]

Zero logic in you post IMO.  Are you a parent?  Are you not familiar with the idea of making sure your young children are covered up at night?   

Well being logic 

She wasn't going to to do that anyway was she - make sure her little ones were covered up

If the door hadn't of slammed -  she would have gone straight back out

But hey your right a caring parent would have done that - but she wasn't going to was she.


As for asking what I would do VS - I'm not the one who left the little ones alone am i