Podcasts by Mark Saunokonoko of 9News.

[jassi]

Says a useless detective.   Lets see what a real detective had to say -


Mr Redwood said: “One reading of the evidence suggest the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction and elements of surveillance. We see a number of men lurking in and around in the day.”

That means that there are other interpretations - or there were at the time of his statement, which is quite some time ago.

[jassi]

Would you be kind enough to refresh my memory?  I can remember a child who took notice of 5A because a relative had lived there previously, but I can't recall her name.  Is that the one?  Can you remember her name?

 

The balcony on block 6 was ideally suited to viewing the media circus that deployed on 4 May 2007. So IF the butts actually existed, it would be necessary to clarify when they were deposited.

DNA should have been able to identify if they was down to one heavy smoker, or a number of bored hacks.

[Venturi Swirl]

A bit late in the day for statistics now if they have pencil man in their sights. The statistics must be wrong if he had a pencil in his pocket.

But you've demonstrated beyond doubt that the statistics are right.  Therefore it is clear that Madeleine was not abducted.  It is your moral imperative to tell the Met that Pencil Man was an innocent bystander who'd somehow become stuck outside Madeleine's apartment and insist that they turn their attention to the parents who are guilty as your mathematics so brilliantly proves.  Stop dicking about on here and do something seriously useful in bringing this case to its rightful conclusion.

[Venturi Swirl]

DNA should have been able to identify if they was down to one heavy smoker, or a number of bored hacks.

Sadly the PJ didn't think it was necessary to find that out.

[jassi]

A bit late in the day for statistics now if they have pencil man in their sights. The statistics must be wrong if he had a pencil in his pocket.

Do you think he was  a HHH pencil man, a real hard man?

[Erngath]

Ah the wonderful detective Mr Redwood who done the most remarkable job of NOT solving the case.

You any other examples of real detectives on the case?

Yes, Amaral!
 

[Lace]

Would you be kind enough to refresh my memory?  I can remember a child who took notice of 5A because a relative had lived there previously, but I can't recall her name.  Is that the one?  Can you remember her name?

 

The balcony on block 6 was ideally suited to viewing the media circus that deployed on 4 May 2007.  So IF the butts actually existed, it would be necessary to clarify when they were deposited.

Here is her statement -

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/T_M_S_AGE_12.htm

[Erngath]

And we all know what that detective had to say on the case.

Good example IMO!

You think so?

[Lace]

Ah the wonderful detective Mr Redwood who done the most remarkable job of NOT solving the case.

You any other examples of real detectives on the case?

He retired when the case was ongoing.

[ShiningInLuz]

DNA should have been able to identify if they was down to one heavy smoker, or a number of bored hacks.

I wasn't suggesting bored hacks, though that balcony would have been a great location for a photographer or a video team.  I can't remember any media output to suggest that was the case.  Mind you, I would have to factor in the trees of 2007.

 

I have seen firsthand two media circuses in Luz since I first became interested in the MBM case - OG Luz dig 2014 and 10th anniversary at St Vincent's.

A most revealing thing is the number of 'passers-by' who were most curious about both activities.  It's not often you get to see a media scrum live.

[Lace]

Do you think he was  a HHH pencil man, a real hard man?

How long did it take to think of that? 

[Venturi Swirl]

Is there any other examples of UK police sending fag butts off for analysis from properties not connected to the case when a person is reported missing?

The location of the DNA butts was potentially significant.  If you think it wasn't perhaps you could tell us why not, oh actually no need - your statistics already prove there was no abductor. 

[Lace]

Actually reading it now,  it was a pen he had and not a pencil   

[Venturi Swirl]

Yes, he retired without solving the case despite saying he intended to.

Does that make him a great detective then?

One day he is going to produce the ace from up his sleeve, then it's game over for the McCanns. 

[Lace]

Yes, he retired without solving the case despite saying he intended to.

Does that make him a great detective then?

What he managed to do when he was investigating was good yes,  he concluded that the McCann's and their friends weren't suspects.