Sunday Times claim that Smith e-fits had been suppressed for 5 years.

[Montclair]

So why did The PJ produce The Confessions at The Trial?  The Ciprianos did refute the confessions, and much good did it do either of them  as there wasn't any other evidence.  And not a scrap of forensics.  The PJ didn't even test the so called blood in the so called fridge.

You obviously know very little about the case. It is not the PJ who produces evidence at trials, it the Ministério Público. They can produce the confessions but if the defendent does not confirm them (BTW, João Cipriano confessed in court) they are not considered part of the evidence by the judge during the trial. Understand? For a case with no other evidence, I wonder why the brother and sister lost all of their appeals to the higher courts.

[imustpointout]

So the alleged paedophile ring that the Mcccanns believe are holding their daughter hostage have had an extra 5 years with her due to the suppression of information by her parents that is now being trumpeted as vital to the investigation.

How does everyone feel about that then?

I believe that it twice you have mentioned it this morning - why don't you open a paedophile ring topic?

[stephen25000]

So the alleged paedophile ring that the Mcccanns believe are holding their daughter hostage have had an extra 5 years with her due to the suppression of information by her parents that is now being trumpeted as vital to the investigation.

How does everyone feel about that then?

Inexcusable.

Now let's see how the mccann supporters respond.

[stephen25000]

That is a question for the directors alone.

Now who are they exactly ?

[Aiofe]

Do you expect Anne to translate them for you? Why don't you use Google translate?

555 pages in a pdf.

Not really a reference, more a maze.

Maybe I will start to give cites in Finnish, as that is easy for me to read!

[icabodcrane]

So the alleged paedophile ring that the Mcccanns believe are holding their daughter hostage have had an extra 5 years with her due to the suppression of information by her parents that is now being trumpeted as vital to the investigation.

How does everyone feel about that then?

This is a crucial question cariad ...  and it is astonishing that the McCanns have yet to respond to it

It is not  just  hiding information that they are being accused of,  it is hiding information which might  have led to Madeleine being found

[Lyall]

So the alleged paedophile ring that the Mcccanns believe are holding their daughter hostage have had an extra 5 years with her due to the suppression of information by her parents that is now being trumpeted as vital to the investigation.

How does everyone feel about that then?

It displays yet again a lack of urgency doesn't it, Cariad. A lack of urgency has been shown again and again throughout the history of this case. No proof in itself but definitely I would say indicative.

[imustpointout]

it is fascinating that Mccann opposers suddenly believe in and are willing to discuss an abductor when it includes a paedo?

How weird.

[Jazzy]

It displays yet again a lack of urgency doesn't it, Cariad. A lack of urgency has been shown again and again throughout the history of this case. No proof in itself but definitely I would say indicative.

So there is no urgency on the part of the Mccanns to have their missing child returned?

[Lyall]

So there is no urgency on the part of the Mccanns to have their missing child returned?

That's what the case history shows us IMO.

[imustpointout]

the re-interview of the Smiths that Amaral says was arranged - was cancelled by the PJ after he left.

[Wonderfulspam]

So there is no urgency on the part of the Mccanns to have their missing child returned?

No, it doesn't look like it & I don't think it ever really has.

[Eleanor]

You obviously know very little about the case. It is not the PJ who produces evidence at trials, it the Ministério Público. They can produce the confessions but if the defendent does not confirm them (BTW, João Cipriano confessed in court) they are not considered part of the evidence by the judge during the trial. Understand? For a case with no other evidence, I wonder why the brother and sister lost all of their appeals to the higher courts.

Oh, so they did produce The Confessions in Court.  I thought you said that this wasn't allowed.  Fibbing, were you?

[Cariad]

I believe that it twice you have mentioned it this morning - why don't you open a paedophile ring topic?

The topic is the suppression of information that might have lead to the safe return of Madeleine 5 years ago. It is the Mccans who have claimed that she is being held by Paedophiles, not me.

I was referring to their belief that she is alive and currently in grave danger and yet they have hindered her rescue.

[Jazzy]

No, it doesn't look like it & I don't think it ever really has.

That is ridiculous. The parents of a missing child don't want her back? Is there not a jot of compassion within you?