Would It Be Possible For Madeleine To Live A 'Normal' Life Elsewhere?

[Robittybob1]

I'm still picking Madeleine has been taken in a child replacement scenario.
In my theory the deceased child was left in the apartment and later retrieved, so that left cadaver odour and foreign DNA in the McCann's apartment.
So whoever lost a child at PdL or even at the OC that night are the parents who have her today.

Someone known to the McCanns IMO is the link between the McCann family and this other family.  Maybe both sets of parents don't know each other but have someone known in common.

Does SY know the current whereabouts of all the families who were at OC that week?  There needs to be something like a roll call.

[jassi]

I'm still picking Madeleine has been taken in a child replacement scenario.
In my theory the deceased child was left in the apartment and later retrieved, so that left cadaver odour and foreign DNA in the McCann's apartment.
So whoever lost a child at PdL or even at the OC that night are the parents who have her today.

Someone known to the McCanns IMO is the link between the McCann family and this other family.  Maybe both sets of parents don't know each other but have someone known in common.

Does SY know the current whereabouts of all the families who were at OC that week?

As they were of a number of nationalities and it was 12 years ago, I think it unlikely

[Robittybob1]

As they were of a number of nationalities and it was 12 years ago, I think it unlikely

Could this be why they are looking for a specific person?  Are they doing a roll call.  They would also need a DNA sample from all the children who are in the families.  For it would be possible for Madeleine to have taken over the identity of one of the children.  It isn't good enough to know if such and such is alive but whether such and such is who the parents say they are.  DNA testing is the only way to check this.

[Robittybob1]

I would imagine most of the families would be rather straight forward to check out, as their addresses will still be the same.

[jassi]

Could this be why they are looking for a specific person?  Are they doing a roll call.  They would also need a DNA sample from all the children who are in the families.  For it would be possible for Madeleine to have taken over the identity of one of the children.  It isn't good enough to know if such and such is alive but whether such and such is who the parents say they are.  DNA testing is the only way to check this.

Why limit yourself to OC guests?
Anyone meeting whatever your criteria are within a 50K radius of PDL would need to be looked at - just for starters.

An impossible task - IMO

[barrier]

It isn't the responsibility of Scotland Yard.  But Madeleine McCann remains a British Citizen lost abroad.  This is the responsibility of The British Government who promise the right of passage by the right of Passport to travel freely and without hindrance.
This is why The Home Office is paying for the ongoing investigation.

I restrict myself from saying anything further to your spurious comment.  Perhaps you should do the same.

You think I haven't noticed that you could be stalking me?

I responded to sadie you took the cudgel up and responded to me,thats stalking me.

[Robittybob1]

Why limit yourself to OC guests?
Anyone meeting whatever your criteria are within a 50K radius of PDL would need to be looked at - just for starters.

An impossible task - IMO

There is in my theory a common acquaintance as a link between the two families, and the knowledge that one  of the Tapas 9 is a doctor (to examine the deceased child).

Locals would just use the local doctor services IMO.

[barrier]

Could this be why they are looking for a specific person?  Are they doing a roll call.  They would also need a DNA sample from all the children who are in the families.  For it would be possible for Madeleine to have taken over the identity of one of the children.  It isn't good enough to know if such and such is alive but whether such and such is who the parents say they are.  DNA testing is the only way to check this.

Thing is Rob,who says they are looking at a specific person,the lead investigators it seem's, the press!

[Robittybob1]

Thing is Rob,who says they are looking at a specific person,the lead investigators it seem's, the press!

That is the impression I got, OK it was an article in the press.

"Madeleine McCann breakthrough? Police 'close in on new suspect' - 'All very secret'"  https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1143831/madeleine-mccann-scotland-yard-new-suspect-investigation-portugal

"“It’s all very secret but it always is with the Madeleine case. Only the police know who the suspect is.”  Not much substance to back this up.

[barrier]

That is the impression I got, OK it was an article in the press.

"Madeleine McCann breakthrough? Police 'close in on new suspect' - 'All very secret'"  https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1143831/madeleine-mccann-scotland-yard-new-suspect-investigation-portugal

"“It’s all very secret but it always is with the Madeleine case. Only the police know who the suspect is.”  Not much substance to back this up.

Its "all very secret" should be the give away.

[Eleanor]

I responded to sadie you took the cudgel up and responded to me,thats stalking me.

Then in that case please don't respond  to any of my replies in future, which you have done several times,  And not just o nce.
 I am beginning to feel hounded by your perpetual attacks on any thing I have to say.
 
Not that any of them are even remotely relevant.  Just don't take me on, our kid.  I am so much better at this then you will ever be.

[barrier]

Then in that case please don't respond  to any of my replies in future, which you have done several times,  And not just o nce.
 I am beginning to feel hounded by your perpetual attacks on any thing I have to say.
 
Not that any of them are even remotely relevant.  Just don't take me on, our kid.  I am so much better at this then you will ever be.

Rather personal isn't it?

[jassi]

Rather personal isn't it?

Somewhat aggressive I would say. Likely to be against the rules.

[The General]

Somewhat aggressive I would say. Likely to be against the rules.

Should be deleted really.

[Eleanor]

Rather personal isn't it?

I think that it time that that we called quits, you and me.  I don't dislike you.