A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[jassi]

So the police are not looking at the McCanns.  At least Amaral has confirmed this.  So we can dispense with the notion that the police are waiting to pounce on the McCanns anytime soon.  They are not suspects.  Period.

But I thought Amaral was proven liar, so how can you believe what he says ?

[ShiningInLuz]

Did you watch Nicky Morgan on daytime tv trying to explain the Tory policy of recruiting 50,000 more nurses?  Well in this instance I am Piers Morgan and you are Nicky Morgan.  Look it up if you don’t understand the reference.

What's daytime TV got to do with anything?

 

[Venturi Swirl]

But I thought Amaral was proven liar, so how can you believe what he says ?

Well this was the question I asked at the beginning.  How are sceptics processing this information? Either Amaral is talking bollocks or he isn’t.  What do you think? 

[Venturi Swirl]

What's daytime TV got to do with anything?

 

Go and have a siesta dear, you’ll feel better after a little nap. 

[jassi]

Well this was the question I asked at the beginning.  How are sceptics processing this information? Either Amaral is talking bollocks or he isn’t.  What do you think?

No idea, as have neither seen, heard , or read anything he has produced for some considerable time.

I know he infuriates supporters, which is good, but I pay little heed to him as he is peripheral to any current activity.

[Venturi Swirl]

No idea, as have neither seen, heard , or read anything he has produced for some considerable time.

I know he infuriates supporters, which is good, but I pay little heed to him as he is peripheral to any current activity.

You have seen what he claims in this latest report, or did you close your eyes when those posts appeared?  He claims the police are looking at a German paedophile in connection with the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.    You appear not to be the slightest bit interested, which is odd for someone who has been following the case for years.  Ach well, nowt so queer as folk.   

[jassi]

You have seen what he claims in this latest report, or did you close your eyes when those posts appeared?  He claims the police are looking at a German paedophile in connection with the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.    You appear not to be the slightest bit interested, which is odd for someone who has been following the case for years.  Ach well, nowt so queer as folk.   

No, no ,Its Amaral I'm not interested in, not the case in general.

I haven't read what he said as I only entered the thread partway through and haven't bothered reading back.

[Venturi Swirl]

No, no ,Its Amaral I'm not interested in, not the case in general.

I haven't read what he said as I only entered the thread partway through and haven't bothered reading back.

Yeah right.  Perhaps a sceptic who is following the thread has a view then.  Or perhaps not.

[The General]

Yeah right.  Perhaps a sceptic who is following the thread has a view then.  Or perhaps not.

It looks to me that he's responding to a question regarding the suspect, not necessarily contradicting his own narrative, but merely stating that the German wasn't the man in question pertaining to the 'new information'.
And he might be getting a few quid. I'd sell next door's cat for £20 (and they haven't even got one).

[jassi]

Yeah right.  Perhaps a sceptic who is following the thread has a view then.  Or perhaps not.

When the thread started it had nothing to do with Amaral, he just seems to have crept in part way through.

[Venturi Swirl]

It looks to me that he's responding to a question regarding the suspect, not necessarily contradicting his own narrative, but merely stating that the German wasn't the man in question pertaining to the 'new information'.
And he might be getting a few quid. I'd sell next door's cat for £20 (and they haven't even got one).

which, if you believe him to be telling the truth (not just saying any old crap for £20) then the McCanns are not prime suspects, which some people who post here continue to believe.

[kmc]

Well this was the question I asked at the beginning.  How are sceptics processing this information? Either Amaral is talking bollocks or he isn’t.  What do you think?

I remember at the time of the interview when Amaral first mentioned the German pedophile, that to me it sounded as if the man in question had been arrested but not necessarily charged.  As a result, I thought it may have related to a pedophile called Andreas V - who at that time had recently been arrested but not yet found guilty - images of him are scarce but he does look a bit like the thick set Smithman e-fit.  What did stand out about him is that 1. The trial documented about 1000 cases of abuse in German starting from 2008...so I wonder where he was before that.  2.  Pre-trial the police 'lost' a LOT of the evidence.  3. A bit like Raymond Hewlett he lived like a traveller. 4. He was able to foster a 6 year old female child even though there were years of rumours about him and children.  5. His victims were mostly girls and also very young victims.   Anyhow, we will have to wait and see if it is him.   Although, I did think it was interesting that Amaral dropped in the similarity to Gerry....it is almost as if he is making sure that if it turns out that the guy in question is the abductor, that he should be forgiven for his assumption that the abductor was Gerry.

[Venturi Swirl]

I remember at the time of the interview when Amaral first mentioned the German pedophile, that to me it sounded as if the man in question had been arrested but not necessarily charged.  As a result, I thought it may have related to a pedophile called Andreas V - who at that time had recently been arrested but not yet found guilty - images of him are scarce but he does look a bit like the thick set Smithman e-fit.  What did stand out about him is that 1. The trial documented about 1000 cases of abuse in German starting from 2008...so I wonder where he was before that.  2.  Pre-trial the police 'lost' a LOT of the evidence.  3. A bit like Raymond Hewlett he lived like a traveller. 4. He was able to foster a 6 year old female child even though there were years of rumours about him and children.  5. His victims were mostly girls and also very young victims.   Anyhow, we will have to wait and see if it is him.   Although, I did think it was interesting that Amaral dropped in the similarity to Gerry....it is almost as if he is making sure that if it turns out that the guy in question is the abductor, that he should be forgiven for his assumption that the abductor was Gerry.

My thought exactly.

[barrier]

I remember at the time of the interview when Amaral first mentioned the German pedophile, that to me it sounded as if the man in question had been arrested but not necessarily charged.  As a result, I thought it may have related to a pedophile called Andreas V - who at that time had recently been arrested but not yet found guilty - images of him are scarce but he does look a bit like the thick set Smithman e-fit.  What did stand out about him is that 1. The trial documented about 1000 cases of abuse in German starting from 2008...so I wonder where he was before that.  2.  Pre-trial the police 'lost' a LOT of the evidence.  3. A bit like Raymond Hewlett he lived like a traveller. 4. He was able to foster a 6 year old female child even though there were years of rumours about him and children.  5. His victims were mostly girls and also very young victims.   Anyhow, we will have to wait and see if it is him.   Although, I did think it was interesting that Amaral dropped in the similarity to Gerry....it is almost as if he is making sure that if it turns out that the guy in question is the abductor, that he should be forgiven for his assumption that the abductor was Gerry.

Or rule out this look alike,back to the beginning it'll be,imo of course.Its taking OG an age to fathom it out,back in 2016 Hogan Howe talked of the last lead.

[Wonderfulspam]

Or rule out this look alike,back to the beginning it'll be,imo of course.Its taking OG an age to fathom it out,back in 2016 Hogan Howe talked of the last lead.

Back in 2017 officers (all 4 of them) were said to have 'searched all over Europe' for that female suspect who held the key to solving the entire case!

I wonder whatever happened to her?  Perhaps she was abducted.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/police-identify-new-female-suspect-madeleine-mccann-case-disappearance-portugal-metropolitan-police-a7711226.html