New European Laws come into effect re cross-border crimes.

[icabodcrane]

It was not a reenactment.

Yes it was

Janosch became   'the abductor'  ...  complete with sinister expressions

All done in complete silence

Creepy beyond words 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Yes it was

Janosch became   'the abductor'  ...  complete with sinister expressions

All done in complete silence

Creepy beyond words

A re-enactment is a recreation of something that we know happened.

This was an experiment to see if it was possible that something happened.

(And creepy beyond words).

[AnneGuedes]

Yes, the bed position is the main problem with that theory.

Don't think it's a bad idea however to see if, in principle, the window shutters / window could have been opened from the outside.

No. The window was blocked.

[pathfinder73]

Yes, the bed position is the main problem with that theory.

Don't think it's a bad idea however to see if, in principle, the window shutters / window could have been opened from the outside.

Could the window be opened from the outside without leaving any trace of evidence? Not according to that expert in the Truth of the Lie documentary and no evidence was found - not even glove marks.

[AnneGuedes]

Yes it was

Janosch became   'the abductor'  ...  complete with sinister expressions

All done in complete silence

Creepy beyond words

[sadie]

ROFL !
The things someone has the courage to do to become famous !

How rude !

[sadie]

Yes, the bed position is the main problem with that theory.

Don't think it's a bad idea however to see if, in principle, the window shutters / window could have been opened from the outside.

Heris theory is quite possible Sherlock.  The bed doesn't cover the entire window opening, by any means. 

In his theory IIRC Heri thinks that Madeleine came over to the window, so she was standing and if she was reassured by someone she knew perhaps saying that Mummy and Daddy had asked him/her to fetch her, then Madeleine could have been lifted like that.

However, no fibres we are told ... or marks on the cill.  I think it less likely than the front door ... but it is a possibility.

[AnneGuedes]

How rude !

[sadie]

You think being rude to a professional investigator with sterling qualifications in criminal investigation, a man who is working hard to help solve this case, is OK do you Anne?

Says more about you than it does about Heri.

Oceans more, in fact, and decent people will be reading this. 

[icabodcrane]

You think being rude to a professional investigator with sterling qualifications in criminal investigation, a man who is working hard to help solve this case, is OK do you Anne?

Says more about you than it does about Heri.

Oceans more, in fact, and decent people will be reading this.

Janosch took his  'theory'  to the British  tabloids     

What purpose did that serve  ? 

Professional investigator my Jim Royle

[sadie]

Eat your hat Icabod.  Apologies would not come amiss.

Just cos he doesn't think what you think about the case, is NOT a reason to abuse Heri


http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://espacioexterior.blogspot.com/&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dheriberto%2Bjanosch%2Bgonz%25C3%25A1lez%26rls%3Dcom.microsoft:en-gb:IE-SearchBox%26rlz%3D1I7RNQN_enGB457

Heriberto Janosch González.
 
Master of Investigation in Psychology.
Psychologist and Educator,
Master of Investigation in Psychology.
Expert's Degree in Criminology.
Expert's Degree in Criminology. Madrid.



What are your special qualifications, Icabod ?

[icabodcrane]

Eat your hat Icabod.  Apologies would not come amiss.

Just cos he doesn't think what you think about the case, is NOT a reason to abuse Heri


http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://espacioexterior.blogspot.com/&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dheriberto%2Bjanosch%2Bgonz%25C3%25A1lez%26rls%3Dcom.microsoft:en-gb:IE-SearchBox%26rlz%3D1I7RNQN_enGB457

Heriberto Janosch González.
 
Master of Investigation in Psychology.
Psychologist and Educator,
Master of Investigation in Psychology.
Expert's Degree in Criminology.
Expert's Degree in Criminology. Madrid.



What are your special qualifications, Icabod ?

I have no  'special qualifications'   

As  to apologies    ...  what for   ?  ...  for asking Janosch what purpose it served for him to speak to a British tabloid about his theory  ? 

 

[a.baker]

I would imagine that if a stranger appeared at the bedroom window Madeleine would have screamed the place down in fright,not happily gone over and chatted with him/her. Unless of course the person was not a stranger. And anyway,in both sightings (if either one was Madeleine) the child appeared asleep so how would this tally with alleged abductor lifting her out of the window on the pretext of going to find her parents?

[Sherlock Holmes]

I have no  'special qualifications'   

As  to apologies    ...  what for   ?  ...  for asking Janosch what purpose it served for him to speak to a British tabloid about his theory  ?

Are you this is correct, icabod?

I remember you asked Heriberto Janosch this question several times.

But I don't remember him clarifying the issue for you.