Podcasts by Mark Saunokonoko of 9News.

[Robittybob1]

Rob get with it. Read back, the cites were provided.

Provided by you or someone else?

[jassi]

I know it was a suggestion but you cannot say that it could not have happened.
Therefore to use a one-sided, hearsay conversation as proof that Gerry knew that paedophile/ paedophiles were in the vicinity of Luz is ridiculous.

Its a report of what Gerry said, not an interpretation of what he may or may not have known.

[Venturi Swirl]

Your responses on the Graham Mackenzie statement lead me to believe that you and many of the other supporters are in complete denial and are incapable of dealing with the evidence that you are presented with.

I can report what I hear people say quite accurately, I don't see why Graham Mackenzie should be any different.
Do you?

What does hearsay mean? 

[Erngath]

Its a report of what Gerry said, not an interpretation of what he may or may not have known.

It's a report of an overheard  one sided conversation which is being used as proof that Gerry McCann knew paedophiles were in the vicinity of Luz
I'm not disagreeing with was was in the report, just challenging if it is correct to use that one sided overheard and rather vague report as proof.

[sadie]

Little Alesha McPhail didn't!

Little Carolina Santos didn't either.  She walked off hand in hand with her abductor

[ShiningInLuz]

What does hearsay mean?

Person A says that person B said that person C said.

Straightforward.

[Venturi Swirl]

Person A says that person B said that person C said.

Straightforward.

Can I remind you of where you decided to butt into this conversation?

I wrote:
Quote from: Vertigo Swirl on Today at 11:31:11 AM
Where is the head banging a wall emoticon?  What Gerry was reported to have said was not first hand.  FGS.

You wrote:

Actually, it was.

---

Gerry is person B, Mackenzie is person A.  How is what Gerry said a first hand account if he is person B?

[Venturi Swirl]

I don't give a flying Francis Bacon what it means. I know what Graham Mackenzie told the police he heard means. It means at 11 o'clock on May 3rd Gerry was on the phone telling someone that paedophile gangs were operating in Portugal and he thought they had abducted one of his children.

Is there any reason you know of, why Graham Mackenzie wouldn't be as good as me at reporting accurately what he heard was the question I asked you?  Had he been diagnosed with dementia for example?

"Along the lines of" means by his own admission the statement he gave was not accurate, but his interpretation of what he heard.  A second hand account.  Now tell me where I am wrong? 

[Venturi Swirl]

I asked you first. So your question to me is second hand. Get in the queue. So why would he been any less accurate than me at reporting what he heard?

I can give an accurate along the lines account of what shocked me four months earlier every single time. Why do you think Graham Mackenzie would be any different?

You have 100% accurate recall of what you heard someone say on the phone 4 months ago as does Graham Mackenzie?  OK, you're both obviously superhuman then.  Well done!

[pathfinder73]

He said that after Gerry had opened the shutters from the outside,   so it seems that Gerry managed it without leaving a trace.

Notice he says ALMOST impossible,  fancy that, ey.

Who witnessed Gerry doing this apart from his wife who then got Dianne to try which makes perfect sense to clowns

[ShiningInLuz]

Who witnessed Gerry doing this apart from his wife who then got Dianne to try raising them. Clown central springs to mind

Smudged prints?

[pathfinder73]

Little Alesha McPhail didn't!

Madeleine would as Mrs Fenn heard.

[G-Unit]

I don't give a flying Francis Bacon what it means. I know what Graham Mackenzie told the police he heard means. It means at 11 o'clock on May 3rd Gerry was on the phone telling someone that paedophile gangs were operating in Portugal and he thought they had abducted one of his children.

Is there any reason you know of, why Graham Mackenzie wouldn't be as good as me at reporting accurately what he heard was the question I asked you?  Had he been diagnosed with dementia for example?

Unfortunately the UK police didn't tie down the time of this conversation.  Crimestoppers said 11pm, but McKenzie's LP statement didn't confirm it; that was much more vague. Other statements suggest that Gerry McCann was at the Main Reception of the Ocean Club at 11pm meeting the GNR officers.

[Lace]

Who witnessed Gerry doing this apart from his wife who then got Dianne to try which makes perfect sense to clowns

Are you calling me a clown?

Did you watch Peter Mac's video?    He pushed the shutters up no trouble at all.   No damage nothing to prove he had done so.

You seem to imply that things are not true,  but only those that suit you.

[Lace]

It would be a one sided conversation with Gerry lol. The witness heard Gerry blaming paedos and this will be important if they solve it.

How do you know that someone may have mentioned to Gerry about there being paedo's in the area?    If I found my child missing and the window open I would think someone had taken my child and paedo would be the first thing I thought of,  wouldn't you?

The Police mentioned not long after Madeleine went missing that if a paedo had taken her the odds are he would have dumped her body within a couple of hours,  now why would the Police be talking paedo's?