News and current affairs from the Portuguese Algarve.

[ShiningInLuz]

my reply has been deleted...

OK, let's leave it at that.

[Mr Gray]

OK, let's leave it at that.

Perhaps I will ...perhaps I wont

[Robittybob1]

my reply has been deleted...

Don't you recall John asked topics like that not to be discussed.

[Venturi Swirl]

I refuse to believe that any police force investigating the disappearance of Madeleine MCCann would be satisfied with a confession of body “occultation “ and a resulting suspended two year sentence.  Apart from the PJ that is.  It beggars belief.  How would it resolve the issue of how, where, when and why the child died to their satisfaction? 

[ShiningInLuz]

I refuse to believe that any police force investigating the disappearance of Madeleine MCCann would be satisfied with a confession of body “occultation “ and a resulting suspended two year sentence.  Apart from the PJ that is.  It beggars belief.  How would it resolve the issue of how, where, when and why the child died to their satisfaction?

It wouldn't.

That's the whole point.

In offering a 'deal' to Kate of body occultation, it makes it as clear as day that the PJ had no idea of how, where when and why MBM died.  Nor where the body was.

[Erngath]

It wouldn't.

That's the whole point.

In offering a 'deal' to Kate of body occultation, it makes it as clear as day that the PJ had no idea of how, where when and why MBM died.  Nor where the body was.

If the PJ had no idea of how where, when Madeleine Beth McCann died, why offer Kate " a deal " ?
Why Kate?

I did use Madeleine's full name, as did VS.

[Mr Gray]

It wouldn't.

That's the whole point.

In offering a 'deal' to Kate of body occultation, it makes it as clear as day that the PJ had no idea of how, where when and why MBM died.  Nor where the body was.

If you read amarals book the did....amaral thought he could prove maddie died in teh apartment

[ShiningInLuz]

If the PJ had no idea of how where, when Madeleine Beth McCann died, why offer Kate " a deal " ?
Why Kate?

I did use Madeleine's full name, as did VS.

According to Kate's book, Matthew Oldfield shouted in anguish when it was put to him by the PJ that he had opened the window, raised the shutter, and passed Madeleine through to an accomplice.

Oldfield himself gave nothing to support this allegation, AFAIK.

The alarm was raised around 10pm when Kate declared MBM was missing.

In Gerry's check, there was still the remnants of daylight.  By Matthew's non-check, there wasn't.  By Kate's check there wasn't.

So why NOT check out Kate for body occultation?

[ShiningInLuz]

If you read amarals book the did....amaral thought he could prove maddie died in teh apartment

In Amaral's book he suggests accidental death plus body occultation.

Maximum sentence 2 years.

[Erngath]

According to Kate's book, Matthew Oldfield shouted in anguish when it was put to him by the PJ that he had opened the window, raised the shutter, and passed Madeleine through to an accomplice.

Oldfield himself gave nothing to support this allegation, AFAIK.

The alarm was raised around 10pm when Kate declared MBM was missing.

In Gerry's check, there was still the remnants of daylight.  By Matthew's non-check, there wasn't.  By Kate's check there wasn't.

So why NOT check out Kate for body occultation?

What do you mean by "check out Kate for body occupation"?

[Robittybob1]

According to Kate's book, Matthew Oldfield shouted in anguish when it was put to him by the PJ that he had opened the window, raised the shutter, and passed Madeleine through to an accomplice.

Oldfield himself gave nothing to support this allegation, AFAIK.

The alarm was raised around 10pm when Kate declared MBM was missing.

In Gerry's check, there was still the remnants of daylight.  By Matthew's non-check, there wasn't.  By Kate's check there wasn't.

So why NOT check out Kate for body occultation?

Who would Matt Oldfield be passing the child too?  Why would this question ever be asked?

[ShiningInLuz]

What do you mean by "check out Kate for body occupation"?

Occultation.  Please read back.

[Robittybob1]

Occultation.  Please read back.

See why correct spelling is important  Occupation and Occultation similar spelling totally different meanings.

[Mr Gray]

In Amaral's book he suggests accidental death plus body occultation.

Maximum sentence 2 years.

is there a necessity to prove accidental death....or is it possible just to claim it...so a prtuguese man can stab his wife to death...hide the body...suggest she died in an accident ...and get a suspended sentence...is taht how balmy the portuguese courts are

[Mr Gray]

See why correct spelling is important  Occupation and Occultation similar spelling totally different meanings.

are you serious