Sceptics beliefs ?

[barrier]

i think I can say with certainty taht whilst posters here and elsewhere havent moved on from gemmied shutters in the last 12 years ...SY and the PJ have

SY got to a few yrds,theres gold in them there hills,certainly wasn't a body.I wonder how much a yard that was,£thousands,£hundreds of thousands?

[ShiningInLuz]

Much the same as the McCanns who, according to sceptics left a huge trail of clangers, howlers and metaphorical  arrows with “guilty as hell” pointing at their heads yet still managed to dispose of a child’s body so brilliantly, in a tourist resort in the evening without the use of a car, a spade or a fridge freezer that to this day it has never been found.  How did they do it?

Wheelie bin.

[Wonderfulspam]

i think I can say with certainty taht whilst posters here and elsewhere havent moved on from gemmied shutters in the last 12 years ...SY and the PJ have

Yes, they've got as far as theorising that Maddie may have left the apartment on her own, according to the press. Ignoring the window evidence altogether.

[barrier]

So we're happy now then that the burglarductor(s) made good their escape through the patio door and not the non-jemmied window?

Or some one else left by the patio doors.

[Venturi Swirl]

What could they possibly charge her with?

Who talked about charging her for that?  I am talking arousing (further) suspicion.  If Kate is blatantly making up stuff that she claims came from the police files then it stands to reason the police would know she was inventing it and was a liar.  This would not reflect very well on her and if she really is guilty of murder or whatever it is you believe she is guilty of, then providing the police with this sort of ammunition would seem somewhat foolish.  No doubt you have smart answer as to why you are right and I am wrong, I look forward to hearing it. 

[Wonderfulspam]

Wheelie bin.

Ta Da!

[Venturi Swirl]

Wheelie bin.

Oh, you’ve come round to that conclusion now have you?  Was a time when you claimed all Portuguese rubbish was hand sorted and that there was no way a body would have gone unnoticed.  So, if you want to dispose of a body forever in Portugal just chuck it in a bin.  I see...

[Wonderfulspam]

Who talked about charging her for that?  I am talking arousing (further) suspicion.  If Kate is blatantly making up stuff that she claims came from the police files then it stands to reason the police would know she was inventing it and was a liar.  This would not reflect very well on her and if she really is guilty of murder or whatever it is you believe she is guilty of, then providing the police with this sort of ammunition would seem somewhat foolish.  No doubt you have smart answer as to why you are right and I am wrong, I look forward to hearing it.

How would we know if Kate was suspected?
It's not like they'd tell us is it.

[Venturi Swirl]

Ta Da!

If Gerry was Smithman then we know the corpse was uncovered.  So, you think he just tossed an uncovered corpse in a bin and hoped for thr best? 

[Mr Gray]

Yes, they've got as far as theorising that Maddie may have left the apartment on her own, according to the press. Ignoring the window evidence altogether.

They certainly  didnt

[Mr Gray]

Wheelie bin.

What a disgusting suggestion.. And you wonder why the mccanns do not return your emails or offers for help..they probably think you are totally daft

[Wonderfulspam]

If Gerry was Smithman then we know the corpse was uncovered.  So, you think he just tossed an uncovered corpse in a bin and hoped for thr best?

Maybe. It's not impossible is it. Quite quick & simple really, & I've seen nothing to prove that didn't happen.

[barrier]

Oh, you’ve come round to that conclusion now have you?  Was a time when you claimed all Portuguese rubbish was hand sorted and that there was no way a body would have gone unnoticed.  So, if you want to dispose of a body forever in Portugal just chuck it in a bin.  I see...

If a big strapping lad like Corrie McKeague can dissappear into the ether of the waste disposal,how simple for a small un like Madeleine.

[Venturi Swirl]

Maybe. It's not impossible is it. Quite quick & simple really, & I've seen nothing to prove that didn't happen.

LOL.  OK, The body was thrown uncovered in the bin by Smithman.  Now explain the dog alerts to the hire car.

[Wonderfulspam]

What a disgusting suggestion.. And you wonder why the mccanns do not return your emails or offers for help

The Maddie in the bin theory is old news. I've mentioned it many times.