Do the sceptics simply misunderstand the evidence

[Mr Gray]

Lets lok at the, alerts to the, car...


If they had put 50 cars, in a, field... With no sign of which car belonged to the McCann's... Any alerts would have been impressive.

But no... Put a, car covered in McCann stickers in a, car park... And when the dog ignores it call him back a, few, times until he Barks... It's hard to believe  that is, actually what happened.... But it did

Where's the laughing Duck emoji

[Robittybob1]

Dogs read window stickers!

[Alice Purjorick]

So another one who cannot address, the point in question.. And neither, will anyone else

What point in question, of relevance was that then?

[Mr Gray]

Dogs read window stickers!

Excellent point... The dogs dont but the handler does... And the dogs don't call themselves back... The handler does

[Robittybob1]

Excellent point... The dogs dont but the handler does... And the dogs don't call themselves back... The handler does

So if there was no odour Eddie still not going to alert to nothing.

[Mr Gray]

So if there was no odour Eddie still not going to alert to nothing.

Again we need to ask grime... Grime says suggestive... Sceptics say it's confirmed...the sceptics are clearly wrong

[pathfinder73]

They are trained to detect cadaver scent. If they fail in their training then they won't be doing the job. Corroborating evidence is required to prove the positive alerts.

[Mr Gray]

They are trained to detect cadaver scent. If they fail in their training then they won't be doing the job. Corroborating evidence is required to prove the positive alerts.

Yes we know that so as there was no corroborating  evidence the alerts are NOT confirmed

So to claim the alerts, were to cadaver odour is incorrect

[Alice Purjorick]

So another one who cannot address, the point in question.. And neither, will anyone else

If you read carefully you will note I responded to a post by you making a crackpot assertion that there is a "whole sceptic movement".
I am still waiting for you provide evidence of it and that you know of them all, Ace.

[Brietta]

Dogs read window stickers!

Clever Hans effect not to mention Zampo :)

[Alice Purjorick]

Clever Hans effect not to mention Zampo :)

Groundhog Day to the power of plenty....
The tape has now done a complete loop.
Mercy

[Brietta]

Groundhog Day to the power of plenty....
The tape has now done a complete loop.
Mercy

I take it you know of Clever Hans effect ... where the dog can 'read' what its master know and is unconsciously signalling?
Therefore dispensing with the necessity to be capable of reading the McCann stickers for itself.

Similarly, Zampo the cadaver dog alerted at supposed deposition sites ... only problem being that there had never been a mass murderer and there had never been murder victims to justify any alerts.

[Alice Purjorick]

I take it you know of Clever Hans effect ... where the dog can 'read' what its master know and is unconsciously signalling?
Therefore dispensing with the necessity to be capable of reading the McCann stickers for itself.

Similarly, Zampo the cadaver dog alerted at supposed deposition sites ... only problem being that there had never been a mass murderer and there had never been murder victims to justify any alerts.

My views on this case were formed without input from dawgs.
I know dawgs have been used in tracking and sniffing capacities for nearly 300 years.
The dawg is a tool much like any other tool.
If I want to know about tools I look up in the appropriate manual not by visiting sites such as this...

[sadie]

Well what caused the cadaver dog to alert then Davel?

The cadavar dog Eddie also alerts to the dried blood from a living person.  That could have caused it. 
Also the brought home from hospital clothes and belongings from a deceased resident who was Tasmin Silences Grandpa could have caused the alerts ... as could his ashes if his widow stored them at home.
 
ETA:  And as Misty pointed out, Eddie was trained on dead piglets

[misty]

My views on this case were formed without input from dawgs.
I know dawgs have been used in tracking and sniffing capacities for nearly 300 years.
The dawg is a tool much like any other tool.
If I want to know about tools I look up in the appropriate manual not by visiting sites such as this...

You'll find some tools here which are quite good at hitting a nail on the head.