Did Brenda Leyland Have the Right to Due Process ?

[Venturi Swirl]

Sorry but 

I thought you’d enjoy that.  Now tell me only clinically depressed people commit suicide again.

[Mr Gray]

headline..

Kate McCann 'contemplated suicide' after detective's book on Madeleine's disappearance

so if kate had committed suicide would sceptics accept that it was amarals book that caused it or would they say it was other factors in her life...what did the Judge say

[faithlilly]

So when she spoke to Brunt she was feeling better, and over her thoughts of ending it all.  But we now know this wasn’t true, was Brunt supposed to guess she was not telling the truth?

Brunt is an educated professional. Even suggesting she had contemplated suicide should have rung huge alarm bells. You don’t get over feeling suicidal with a few drinks.

I wonder if he told anyone at Sky of this conversation with Brenda. I’m guessing not. Too good a scoop I suppose.

It’s telling they never attempted to doorstep anyone else in the dossier ( cue grinding of false teeth ).

[faithlilly]

I thought you’d enjoy that.  Now tell me only clinically depressed people commit suicide again.

Were Romeo and Juliet real ?

[faithlilly]

headline..

Kate McCann 'contemplated suicide' after detective's book on Madeleine's disappearance

so if kate had committed suicide would sceptics accept that it was amarals book that caused it or would they say it was other factors in her life...what did the Judge say

But she didn’t.

If she had said to Amaral ‘I have become suicidal at the thought that you might publish a book accusing me of a heinous crime’ and when the book was published she did, whose fault do you think that would be ?

[Mr Gray]

But she didn’t.

If she had said to Amaral ‘I have become suicidal at the thought that you might publish a book accusing me of a heinous crime’ and when the book was published she did, whose fault do you think that would be ?

I understand you cant answer the question...it would destroy your argument..

[faithlilly]

I understand you cant answer the question...it would destroy your argument..

I would question whether her loss of reputation really had meant more to her than the loss of her child.

Martin Brunt was told Brenda, due to his doorstepping, had contemplated suicide. None of friends or family at the inquest suggested she had talked about suicide before her doorstepping. Even you can join the dots.

[Mr Gray]

But she didn’t.

If she had said to Amaral ‘I have become suicidal at the thought that you might publish a book accusing me of a heinous crime’ and when the book was published she did, whose fault do you think that would be ?

i asked thefirst question...now my second..
if she had said taht ...do you think amaral would still have published his book

[Mr Gray]

I would question whether her loss of reputation really had meant more to her than the loss of her child.

Martin Brunt was told Brenda, due to his doorstepping, had contemplated suicide. None of friends or family at the inquest suggested she had talked about suicide before her doorstepping. Even you can join the dots.

still no answer

[faithlilly]

i asked thefirst question...now my second..
if she had said taht ...do you think amaral would still have published his book

I think he would have and would have had to live with the fact that he may have contributed to her suicide.

Now you.

If Kate had said to Amaral ‘I have become suicidal at the thought that you might publish a book accusing me of a heinous crime’ and when the book was published she did, whose fault do you think that would be ?

[Erngath]

I would question whether her loss of reputation really had meant more to her than the loss of her child.

Martin Brunt was told Brenda, due to his doorstepping, had contemplated suicide. None of friends or family at the inquest suggested she had talked about suicide before her doorstepping. Even you can join the dots.

I would question whether Brenda's  loss of reputation meant more to her than having lost  the company and pleasure  and love of having her eldest child in her life.

[Venturi Swirl]

Were Romeo and Juliet real ?

No, but their story has been repeated in real life many times.  Now, tell me again that only the clinically depressed commit suicide.

[Mr Gray]

I think he would have and would have had to live with the fact that he may have contributed to her suicide.

should he go ahead

[faithlilly]

No, but their story has been repeated in real life many times.  Now, tell me again that only the clinically depressed commit suicide.

Then why not bring the real life cases here rather than a fictional one ?

[faithlilly]

should he go ahead

I see you’re avoiding my question.