Manhunt by Colin Sutton. Are there comparisons with Madeleine?

[barrier]

is that the one which describes how the family were seen getting on their unicorn and riding off into the sunset?

You have knowledge of what is missing?

[G-Unit]

I thought you were a scholar of the Files?  Go and find it yourself, you probably know the page number better than I do.

As you're the one making the claim the onus is on you to provide the appropriate evidence or withdraw the claim.

[Eleanor]

From the files.

I thought one boat went missing altogether.  They have no paperwork, so how would they know?

And who would see anything on beaches and in inlets in the dark?

[Venturi Swirl]

From the files.

Please can you tell me how that (IMO non sequitur of a reference) answers the question of how the police decided the girl did not look like Madeleine..?

[Venturi Swirl]

As you're the one making the claim the onus is on you to provide the appropriate evidence or withdraw the claim.

Tell you what.  I will supply the reference but only if you agree to acknowledge my efforts and thank me for providing it, instead of ignoring it as usually happens, deal?

[barrier]

Please can you tell me how that (IMO non sequitur of a reference) answers the question of how the police decided the girl did not look like Madeleine..?

As it crossed your mind that some one could well have given a description or that the girl and family were known to those that needed to know.

[barrier]

I thought one boat went missing altogether.  They have no paperwork, so how would they know?

And who would see anything on beaches and in inlets in the dark?

VS was on about the marina in daylight,not isolated beaches and inlets.

[barrier]

I thought one boat went missing altogether.  They have no paperwork, so how would they know?

And who would see anything on beaches and in inlets in the dark?

In that case how does any one know it went missing,or is it another forum/internet myth.

[Venturi Swirl]

As it crossed your mind that some one could well have given a description or that the girl and family were known to those that needed to know.

Lots f things have crossed my mind, where is any evidence that ANY of it crossed the mind of those that mattered, ie: those investiating Madeleine’s disappearance?

[Venturi Swirl]

You have knowledge of what is missing?

No, but the Met do and that is why they had reams of leads to follow up, geddit now?

[Eleanor]

VS was on about the marina in daylight,not isolated beaches and inlets.

So the boat lurked about until dark.

[barrier]

So the boat lurked about until dark.

What boat?

[Eleanor]

What boat?

I can't say.  It might be libellous as I can't prove it.

[G-Unit]

Does your opinion differ?  Do you think the PJ did not thoroughly investigate the McCanns?

The PJ failed to confirm the timeline at the beginning. I can think of some questions they could have asked which would have helped them to do that.

1. Question the Irwins and the Sperreys who were booked into the Tapas at 8.30 and 9 pm respectively.
2. Question the Executive Chef again about his testimony and check if he had witnesses as to the times he went to and returned from the Tapas.
3. Check the statement of Barend Weijdom and his alleged meeting with Paul Wortelboer.
4. Check who informed the nannies at the creche about Madeleine's disappearance and find out how she knew.
5. Find out which Mark Warner employee went into the Duke de Jaollande bar at 10.15 and asked for help with the search.

[Venturi Swirl]

The PJ failed to confirm the timeline at the beginning. I can think of some questions they could have asked which would have helped them to do that.

1. Question the Irwins and the Sperreys who were booked into the Tapas at 8.30 and 9 pm respectively.
2. Question the Executive Chef again about his testimony and check if he had witnesses as to the times he went to and returned from the Tapas.
3. Check the statement of Barend Weijdom and his alleged meeting with Paul Wortelboer.
4. Check who informed the nannies at the creche about Madeleine's disappearance and find out how she knew.
5. Find out which Mark Warner employee went into the Duke de Jaollande bar at 10.15 and asked for help with the search.

To quote Barrier, “there are pages missing, how do you know they didn’t”?  LOL.  But seriously, how do you think the answers to ANY of those questions would have helped establish the guilt or innocence of the McCanns?  Still at least you seem to be conceding that the PJ weren’t very thorough, so not thorough in trying to nail their key suspects, it stands to reason they were even less thorough in investigating possible leads into an abduction doesn’t it.