Shane Mitchell’s whereabouts during the course of the entire evening?

[Nicholas]

In a statement given to police on July 7, 2003, Shane Mitchell said he recalled seeing his brother in the kitchen "mashing tatties".

The High Court in Edinburgh heard that his mother had given a statement the previous day also claiming that Luke was in the kitchen that evening "cooking pies and mashing potatoes".

But the jury previously heard that when Shane was questioned by police on April 14 last year he said he had not seen Luke in the house on the evening of June 30, 2003, and that he had been looking at pornography on his computer in his bedroom.

[Nicholas]

In a statement given to police on July 7, 2003, Shane Mitchell said he recalled seeing his brother in the kitchen "mashing tatties".

The High Court in Edinburgh heard that his mother had given a statement the previous day also claiming that Luke was in the kitchen that evening "cooking pies and mashing potatoes".

But the jury previously heard that when Shane was questioned by police on April 14 last year he said he had not seen Luke in the house on the evening of June 30, 2003, and that he had been looking at pornography on his computer in his bedroom.

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been




Barefaced lies by Shane Mitchell 👆🏽

[Nicholas]

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been




Barefaced lies by Shane Mitchell 👆🏽

Barefaced lies by Corinne Mitchell
👇

When I got home Luke was in the kitchen first of all. Luke then strained the potatoes and mashed them. At that point I think Shane came in and I could smell the pies in the oven and I asked one of them to take them out, commenting that Luke had overdone them

[Nicholas]

Mr Turnbull then asked: "How can it be you gave information to police which was incorrect and then give information about mashing tatties and burnt pies.

"Before you gave that statement did you discuss with anyone what you should say to police?"

Mr Mitchell replied: "In a way."

Mr Turnbull said: "Who"

Mitchell replied: "My mother”

Asked what his mother had said to him after giving her statement Mr Mitchell replied: "She said to me: ‘You came in and Luke was with us and we had tatties for dinner, then you went back out again."

[Nicholas]

Mr Turnbull then asked: "How can it be you gave information to police which was incorrect and then give information about mashing tatties and burnt pies.

"Before you gave that statement did you discuss with anyone what you should say to police?"

Mr Mitchell replied: "In a way."

Mr Turnbull said: "Who"

Mitchell replied: "My mother”

Asked what his mother had said to him after giving her statement Mr Mitchell replied: "She said to me: ‘You came in and Luke was with us and we had tatties for dinner, then you went back out again."

What was Shane Mitchell really doing that night?

Was he helping to dispose of incriminating evidence?

Did Shane Mitchell get the fire started in the garden at around 18:30hrs?

[Nicholas]

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been




Barefaced lies by Shane Mitchell 👆🏽

Shaun Hall told similar bare faced lies in his first police witness statement

Shaun Hall
‘I remained at home with Leigh and X for the rest of the day and overnight in to Sunday morning, 16th December 2001, when at about 9.30am my father collected me in his company car along with Simon
We three then returned to Capel St Mary to collect my mother, from where we then continued on to Lincolnshire
We all had lunch together with my maternal Grandparents, Raymond and Joyce *******, and my mothers brother Steve, and his wife and daughter, X and X *******. There were about eight (8) other persons present whose names I cannot recall
After lunch (at a pub, the name of which I do not recall), we went on to my Grandparents’ home, where we remained until about 5pm
My parents Simon and I then travelled back to Suffolk, where they dropped me off at home at about 7.30pm

(Source: http://theerrorsthatplaguethemiscarriageofjusticemovement.home.blog/2022/06/12/quite-a-hall-tale-part-12a%ef%b8%8f/)


And like Shane Mitchell, Shaun Hall may well have been coached by his mother Lynne Hall or he may have spoken to his killer brother Simon Hall with regards the families movements on Sunday the 16th of Dec 2001

Shaun Hall didn’t travel up to Lincolnshire on that Sunday (He stayed in Ipswich with Leigh and X) - he lied in an attempt to pervert the course of justice

If killer Luke Mitchell and his toxic and abusive mother Corinne, and brother Shane, had nothing to hide, they would have told the truth from the start

[Nicholas]

Who is the female filmed with Corinne Mitchell at around 19:17 (seemingly holding hands) here
👇
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-m-zHEUOFR0

Re Gemma Chapman

That relationship ended but he has since been seen kissing another girl who has joined his mum Corinne on trips to the jail.

[Nicholas]

‘She then revealed that Mitchell phoned her at 12.30am after Jodi's body had been found but he never mentioned that.

She said: 'I kept trying to phone him as he was late and in trouble. He would not answer and then he finally phoned and said, 'I can't talk, I have to go.' 'He phoned back again and when I asked what happened he said, 'I can't tell you.' 'I heard a man's voice in the background and Luke said it was a policeman and I asked to speak to him.'

Mr Turnbull: 'Luke calls you twice and didn't tell you what had happened to Jodi?'

Mrs Mitchell: 'That's right.' Mr Turnbull: 'Because, Mrs Mitchell, you already knew.'



Why did Corinne Mitchell tell the jury her killer son was ‘late’ and ‘in trouble’?

What time did hoaxer Sandra Lean claim the police phoned Corinne Mitchell?

[Nicholas]

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been




Barefaced lies by Shane Mitchell 👆🏽

Look at the lying details Shane Mitchell gave in his statement

[Mr Apples]

Look at the lying details Shane Mitchell gave in his statement

Yes, very telling. From going from saying he saw him mashing tatties in the kitchen, to saying, under oath, that "I honestly don't remember seeing my brother that day. He could have been there." (Cite: https://www.thefreelibrary.com/JODI+PICS+HORROR+OF+MITCHELL%27S+BROTHER%3B+Tears+at+death+trial.-a0126987509). Complete lies, as you say.

Nicholas, I don't know if I've asked you this before, but do you know of anything about Shane Mitchell being spotted in Oxgangs on the evening of 30.06.03? You seem knowledgeable on this case, so any info relating to this particular aspect of the case would be greatly appreciated.

[Nicholas]

Yes, very telling. From going from saying he saw him mashing tatties in the kitchen, to saying, under oath, that "I honestly don't remember seeing my brother that day. He could have been there." (Cite: https://www.thefreelibrary.com/JODI+PICS+HORROR+OF+MITCHELL%27S+BROTHER%3B+Tears+at+death+trial.-a0126987509). Complete lies, as you say.

Nicholas, I don't know if I've asked you this before, but do you know of anything about Shane Mitchell being spotted in Oxgangs on the evening of 30.06.03?

Re Oxgangs
👇

Interesting quote from Parky41, on this very forum, a few years ago:

Why did SM travel into Oxgangs later that evening, after 9pm to get fuel? As this is why he said he travelled there, to fuel up the car? - Are there any scrap merchants near Oxgangs that SM used? A mechanic having access to this place?  Why Oxgangs for fuel? there were many other stations to get fuel? Tesco just up the road? Was SM disposing of evidence? Why was CM's car spotted elsewhere? Was SM driving it? When she claimed to be home all evening? What are these new claims that her car was at the West end of this path later that evening? only being heard now? - Why are we not hearing about these reports from these witness's who came forward? - Why is SL dismissing these as being wrong or mistaken, or idle gossip? - but asking people to consider every other piece of hearsay? Or unproven claims that the defence sought not to use - why does she feel she is somewhat superior in intelligence to every expert in their field?

Parky41, where did you hear about SM travelling to Oxgangs? Please forward a cite. Or did you read it on that private group you are a member of -- the private group, some of whose members allegedly attended Luke Mitchell's trial between November 2004 and January 2005? It would be very useful indeed if you could post a link to this private group (you can even pm me if you don't wish to divulge this group publicly . . . mum's the word, and all that).

I’m of the view Shane Mitchell has threatened both Sandra Lean and his mother Corinne Mitchell from discussing him and his evidence because he was quite probably more involved in the disposable of evidence during the nights ‘events’

Why would Shane Mitchell allegedly go up and down stairs etc allegedly to give his brother a torch (the same brother who has apparently just walked back in the house having not needed a torch at this time)

but then not go out searching with his brother?

Wasn’t (isn’t) Shane Mitchell about ten years older than Luke?

[Nicholas]

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been

Didn’t Shane Mitchell claim his memory was poor was previous drug use?

How then did he recall his brother being ‘happy’ that day?

[Nicholas]

Yes, very telling. From going from saying he saw him mashing tatties in the kitchen, to saying, under oath, that "I honestly don't remember seeing my brother that day. He could have been there." (Cite: https://www.thefreelibrary.com/JODI+PICS+HORROR+OF+MITCHELL%27S+BROTHER%3B+Tears+at+death+trial.-a0126987509). Complete lies, as you say.

Nicholas, I don't know if I've asked you this before, but do you know of anything about Shane Mitchell being spotted in Oxgangs on the evening of 30.06.03?

Sandra Lean and Corinne and Shane Mitchell have intentionally attempted to deflect attention away from this nights ‘outing’ 

[Nicholas]

Yes, very telling. From going from saying he saw him mashing tatties in the kitchen, to saying, under oath, that "I honestly don't remember seeing my brother that day. He could have been there." (Cite: https://www.thefreelibrary.com/JODI+PICS+HORROR+OF+MITCHELL%27S+BROTHER%3B+Tears+at+death+trial.-a0126987509). Complete lies, as you say.

Nicholas, I don't know if I've asked you this before, but do you know of anything about Shane Mitchell being spotted in Oxgangs on the evening of 30.06.03?

Where exactly was Shane Mitchell when his cruel and callous mother went to the police station with her killer son and what exactly was Shane Mitchell doing from the time they left until they arrived back?

Why didn’t Shane Mitchell go with his mother and brother?

Did Corinne Mitchell keep her eldest son updated while she was as the police station?

Did Shane Mitchell phone his mother whilst she was at the police station to find out what was taking her and his kiler bother so long?

Hoaxer Sandra Lean keeps claiming they was no time to empty the log burner of debris etc

Shane Mitchell had hours alone to get rid of this evidence too

[Nicholas]

Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, read sections of Shane’s statement from July 7 to the jury.

I went into the hallway and shouted out and then went upstairs to the bathroom to wash my hands. About five minutes later I came straight back down. When I was in the bathroom I left the door open.

Afterwards I went downstairs into the living-room, then into the kitchen. Luke was standing at the cooker mashing tatties. I could smell burnt steak pies. I did not mention the smell because I did not want to insult him

He was pretty happy. I spoke to him, then my mother. That was the first time I had seen my mother that day and I was talking to her about how her day had been

More double binds

from

‘He was pretty happy, I spoke to him’

to no memory - due to drug use