Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

grime says the alerts are suggestive.....the videos are heavily edited...the police files question the alerts

You will have proof of this heavy editing then? can't wait....

[Mr Gray]

A) I am frequently right, sometimes wrong, not the other way around
B) Suggest/indicate is good enough for me from a professional and ( officially said) an uncorroborated cadaver dog alert is justifiable cause for concern....especially if it is in the last place a missing person was......logic dictates this anyway....
C) Unsure why you use the word confirm when no one else uses it here, is it because you are backtracking from...means nothing at all/rubbish ??

 

might be good enough for you but that is of no consequence...I use the word confirm because that is the word used in the files re Grimes rogatory questions...it's rather an important word

[Mr Gray]

You will have proof of this heavy editing then? can't wait....

yes it is in the files.......it has already been discussed and accepted  to be true

[ferryman]

I haven't seen anything about him being an advisor in canine deployment to be untrue.

What seems to have gone wrong in Jersey was what you'd posted earlier in this thread: he ended up being the de facto deputy crime scene manager to the forensic service manager. And I haven't seen anything to suggest that he was qualified for that job.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3566.msg263530#msg263530

Reading up, FM.

It was Harper who'd stated that Grime was "also the NPIA search
coordinator". No idea where Harper got that idea from.

 His [Grime's] expertise lay purely in the use of dogs in searching, not as a 'search co-ordinator'.

(Operation Rectangle)

ETA.  Harper interpreted these words (of Grime's) as "search coordinator"

I advise
Domestic and International Law enforcement agencies on the
operational deployment of police dogs in the role of homicide
investigation. I develop methods of detecting forensically recoverable
evidence by the use of dogs and facilitate training’.

[mercury]

might be good enough for you but that is of no consequence...I use the word confirm because that is the word used in the files re Grimes rogatory questions...it's rather an important word

As things stand, the cadaver dog alerts remain as unconfirmed cadaverscent....reread the last word previous to "reread"

[mercury]

yes it is in the files.......it has already been discussed and accepted  to be true

Is there any particular reason why you  never give links to support your statements? IE, in this case, where in the files is there proof that the dog videos have been heavily edited?

[ferryman]

As things stand, the cadaver dog alerts remain as unconfirmed cadaverscent....reread the last word previous to "reread"

They stand as unconfirmed (as in meaningless)

[slartibartfast]

yes it is in the files.......it has already been discussed and accepted  to be true

Been discussed, not accepted.

[Mr Gray]

Is there any particular reason why you  never give links to support your statements? IE, in this case, where in the files is there proof that the dog videos have been heavily edited?

it's on this thread about a week ago...doesn't matter if you don't accept it...it's a fact

[mercury]

They stand as unconfirmed (as in meaningless)

Only in your mind though FM not in reality

[slartibartfast]

it's on this thread about a week ago...doesn't matter if you don't accept it...it's a fact

So only discussed then.

[ferryman]

Only in your mind though FM not in reality

I shan't re-hash (yet again!) the words of Mark Harrison which confirms what I say as true.

[mercury]

it's on this thread about a week ago...doesn't matter if you don't accept it...it's a fact

Nothing is fact just because you say so, so yet, another example of laziness in not providing a link to back up statements, par for the course, oh well.... 1/10

[Mr Gray]

Been discussed, not accepted.

that's a matter of opinion

the pj report criticises the alerts as the dogs were repeatedly led back after repeatedly ignoring locations...that's not an opinion..its afact...the videos have been edited so as not to show this..thats a fact too ..due you dispute the videos have been edited and show the alerts in a better light than they actually were

[Mr Gray]

As things stand, the cadaver dog alerts remain as unconfirmed cadaverscent....reread the last word previous to "reread"

that's right...unconfirmed...there is no evidence the dog alerted to cadaver odour