Sorry, I thought commenting on a book involved reading it, so I assumed you meant that's what she'd done;
"She lived it all from the moment on 3 May 2007 when she found the window open and the shutters raised in the children's room and commented about Amaral's profit making disgraceful book on 6 September 2008."
Mind you, many people have commented on his book who don't seem to have read it. Gerry got one thing right;
Gerry – We wouldn’t mind if we had been investigated at the beginning, if they thought that could help. But months later, when the evidence had been lost? It’s that once the suspicion is installed, we can never prove our innocence again.
https://themaddiecasefiles.com/mccanns-in-expresso-interview-06-09-08-t23178.html
Of course the suspicions of the PJ didn't cease after September 2007, it continued until the case was archived and Amaral had not been involved for 10 months.
You really don't make the slightest effort to keep apace with current developments do you? Hence your predilection for dwelling within the confines of groundhog day.
"Of course the suspicions of the PJ didn't cease after September 2007 ... " I have already informed you of precisely that unfortunate situation.
https://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11381.msg688434#msg688434 but as always you've managed to get it wrong.
If the nonsense had continued only
"until the case was archived and Amaral had not been involved for 10 months." that would have been beneficial. But Amaral, with the wholehearted connivance of his chat show friends including Christovao, never gave up involvement after 10 months but kept his show well and truly on the road for fifteen years.
Amaral threw everything he had into maintaining the status quo right up to the time when it became obvious - even to the Portuguese who made Brueckner prime suspect by dint of the evidence - that a huge injustice had been perpetrated by Amaral against the McCanns and his continued obsessive dedication to interfere in Madeleine's case as always to the detriment of solving it and slurring her parents at the same time.
