General discussion about the latest news (not search related)

[slartibartfast]

The cadaver dog only alerted to Kate's clothing, not Gerry's.

But according to some that is immaterial?

[misty]

But according to some that is immaterial?

IMO PJ thought they could get Kate to confess to occulting Madeleine's body (and maybe more) using a combination of Eddie's alerts & the nature of the questions asked. IMO that particular theory was thrown into chaos when Martin Smith came forward & said he was 60/80% sure the man he saw on the night of the 3rd carrying a child was Gerry.
There were no alerts to any of Gerry's clothing.
There was no evidence to implicate Gerry so he had no need to refuse to answer any questions, IMO

[Mr Gray]

But according to some that is immaterial?

As according to Harrison  no inference can be drawn from the alert how can it be, anything other than immaterial

[Mr Gray]

Gerry was told the same and yet he answered every question. How do you explain that ?

I can explain it very easily... Gerry was incenced by the, questioning and decided not to take the advice

[slartibartfast]

I can explain it very easily... Gerry was incenced by the, questioning and decided not to take the advice

So why isn’t he in prison?

[Mr Gray]

So why isn’t he in prison?

Why are you asking me when you already know the answer

[Alice Purjorick]

I can explain it very easily... Gerry was incenced by the, questioning and decided not to take the advice

A less than rational approach if true.

[Mr Gray]

A less than rational approach if true.

I agree

[Mr Gray]

A less than rational approach if true.

so we have Gerry being less than rational because he answered the questions and Kate trying to hide something because she didnt...par for the course

[slartibartfast]

Why are you asking me when you already know the answer

Well we have heard that Kate would have been in prison if she had answered the question, which I assumed you agreed with.

[Mr Gray]

Well we have heard that Kate would have been in prison if she had answered the question, which I assumed you agreed with.

You assumed I agreed with?...is that opinion or fact.

[slartibartfast]

You assumed I agreed with?...is that opinion or fact.

Well that’s clarified that. You don’t think she would have been in prison if she had answered the question.

[Mr Gray]

Well that’s clarified that. You don’t think she would have been in prison if she had answered the question.

I think she may have been

[slartibartfast]

I think she may have been

No fence sitting...

[Mr Gray]

No fence sitting...

im not