Goncalo Amaral.

[G-Unit]

Sorry I forgot Amaral was only the tea boy.

I didn't say that and you know it's not true. He was the coordinator, but he wasn't in charge.

[Venturi Swirl]

I didn't say that and you know it's not true. He was the coordinator, but he wasn't in charge.

So quite ok for him to form an opinion about the McCanns guilt or otherwise without meeting them, Graham Hill on the other hand...

[G-Unit]

So quite ok for him to form an opinion about the McCanns guilt or otherwise without meeting them, Graham Hill on the other hand...

Many many people have formed opinions about the McCann's guilt or innocence without meeting them. When the McCanns wanted to flee Portugal it was the man in charge who they approached and who gave his permission; Encarnacao.

[kizzy]

The German police are now sounding fairly certain that Madeleine is dead and that they have evidence the German did it. 
Whether Graham Hill is an expert on the McCanns or not seems a redundant argument now.

Just shows you believe everything you read - the evidence is only CB told someone she was

[Mr Gray]

posters want to criticise hills lack of knowledge...what is far far  far more important is amarals lack of knowledge.
He claimed


The dogs had a 100% record
They had never been wrong in 200 cases
That they discovered  a cadaver under a slab of concrete in Jersey
That the evidence he produced in the documentary proved maddie died in the appartment

All wrong and considering according to  a report in the Guardian re the libel trial that the main evidence against the McCanns was the alerts...a disater for the investigation

[kizzy]

posters want to criticise hills lack of knowledge...what is far far  far more important is amarals lack of knowledge.
He claimed


The dogs had a 100% record
They had never been wrong in 200 cases
That they discovered  a cadaver under a slab of concrete in Jersey
That the evidence he produced in the documentary proved maddie died in the appartment

All wrong and considering according to  a report in the Guardian re the libel trial that the main evidence against the McCanns was the alerts...a disater for the investigation

All that is going on with CB is circumstantial evidence - IMO GA had more circumstantial on mccs.

The fact is as well - the mccs was definitely there

[Mr Gray]

All that is going on with CB is circumstantial evidence - IMO GA had more circumstantial on mccs.

The fact is as well - the mccs was definitely there

I'm pointing out how much amaral got wrong...facts not opinions.

[Eleanor]

I shudder to think of what The Media will do to Goncalo Amaral over The Cipriano Case if this all proves to be true.

No wonder he went quiet.  He surely must see this coming.

Meanwhile, The Portuguese Judiciary have lost all credibility, even if in not knowing that they had a convicted Paedophile and Rapist rampaging around The Algarve.  Although I don't believe that.

[G-Unit]

posters want to criticise hills lack of knowledge...what is far far  far more important is amarals lack of knowledge.
He claimed


The dogs had a 100% record
They had never been wrong in 200 cases
That they discovered  a cadaver under a slab of concrete in Jersey
That the evidence he produced in the documentary proved maddie died in the appartment

All wrong and considering according to  a report in the Guardian re the libel trial that the main evidence against the McCanns was the alerts...a disater for the investigation

You accuse Amaral of lacking knowledge but ignore the fact that his superiors must have agreed with him otherwise the investigation would have changed direction.

[Mr Gray]

You accuse Amaral of lacking knowledge but ignore the fact that his superiors must have agreed with him otherwise the investigation would have changed direction.

Yes it seems they all got it wrong.. In Harrison's report he states how they had a meeting with the PJ and explained the alerts needed to be verified.. It seems they didn't listen

[Eleanor]

You accuse Amaral of lacking knowledge but ignore the fact that his superiors must have agreed with him otherwise the investigation would have changed direction.

I've included them in Loss of Credibility.  None of them knew about this Convicted Paedophile and Rapist?

I simply do not believe that they didn't know.

[G-Unit]

Yes it seems they all got it wrong.. In Harrison's report he states how they had a meeting with the PJ and explained the alerts needed to be verified.. It seems they didn't listen

Who suggested adding the McCann's villa, clothing and car to the dog's itinerary? In my opinion that was Harrison.

[kizzy]

I'm pointing out how much amaral got wrong...facts not opinions.

You - dont know yet if he did get it wrong fact ....it is only your opinion he did.

Oh and no need to say you understood the evidence - on abduction, there wasn't any.fact

[G-Unit]

I've included them in Loss of Credibility.  None of them knew about this Convicted Paedophile and Rapist?

I simply do not believe that they didn't know.

Was he a convicted rapist at that point? Had the German police notified the Portuguese that he was wanted in Germany? Did anyone draw the attention of the PJ to this man? If so, who were they and what did they say?

[pathfinder73]

The Smith family saw the man with Madeleine that night. Amaral was on the correct path but it is now up to OG  to fully investigate that sighting if they are going to solve this case! If they want to find a body they can start by employing cadaver dogs in boats on Barragem da Bravura lake.