The only opinion that really counts for anything at all atm is the person or people with ALL the available evidence at their disposal. We only have their words to go on, and the person in the best position to comment on what the evidence about CB's involvement reveals is HCW. He says he is 100% certain that CB is involved in Madeleine's murder. Now, you can choose to believe him or disbelieve him but it's only your opinion and doesn't really hold any validity either way. SO, imo best to simply wait and see, give the benefit of the doubt until more information is revealed upon which to make a judgement. I really don't see the point in continuing to keep going round and round in circles about it. In the meantime, one person whose opinion definitely counts for no more than yours or mine is Amaral's. He hasn't been "in the loop" since 2007 so definitely Yesterday's Man. He has no credibility and is best ignored and forgotten IMO.