Is there a plausible, logical theory of abduction?

[jassi]

If

[Mr Gray]

If

of course if......so that is THE most important question...it seems SY believe her

[Alfie]

How goes he know?

Bear in mind they don't all check at the same time, there are not gaps of 20-30 minutes without checkers.

there hardly seems any point attempting to reply to questions now as my responses have a tendency to disappear with alarming regularity.  I suggest anyone who wants to ask me a question PM me in future.

[Alice Purjorick]

If Kate is telling the truth...the window was open which proves third party involvemnent.....its a simple as that

Only in your simple mind.
Ok the window is found open .......................................... now fill in the full SP how the window was opened how the shutter was raised* and an abduction effected allowing for all other conditions that were found to obtain at the time.

* please not the videos as they have been "topped and tailed" to remove the most instructive parts.

[Alice Purjorick]

there hardly seems any point attempting to reply to questions now as my responses have a tendency to disappear with alarming regularity. I suggest anyone who wants to ask me a question PM me in future.

No chance on an open forum. Learn to keep within the rules................simples

[Mr Gray]

Only in your simple mind.
Ok the window is found open .......................................... now fill in the full SP how the window was opened how the shutter was raised* and an abduction effected allowing for all other conditions that were found to obtain at the time.

* please not the videos as they have been "topped and tailed" to remove the most instructive parts.

if my mind was simple you would have a valid point...as it isnt ...you dont


an open window and a truthful Kate proves  a third party involvement ....a criminl unless you have an alternative expalnation

[Alice Purjorick]

if my mind was simple you would have a valid point...as it isnt ...you dont


an open window and a truthful Kate proves  a third party involvement ....a criminl unless you have an alternative expalnation

Third party involvement in what precisely ?

[Mr Gray]

Third party involvement in what precisely ?

in opening the widow and shutters

[slartibartfast]

if my mind was simple you would have a valid point...as it isnt ...you dont


an open window and a truthful Kate proves  a third party involvement ....a criminl unless you have an alternative expalnation

Just classic circular reasoning.

[Mr Gray]

Just classic circular reasoning.

yes classic

[faithlilly]

Coincidence...?   &%+((£  Maybe...  a bit like the coincidence in the Shannon Matthews case perhaps?

But Shannon Matthews hadn't actually been kidnapped.

Add this to the coincidence that two men were seen in PDL on the 3rd of May, both with identical children wearing identical clothing and you have a rather strange set of events.

Of course you do know what Kate says about coincidences ?

[Robittybob1]

But Shannon Matthews hadn't actually been kidnapped.

Add this to the coincidence that two men were seen in PDL on the 3rd of May, both with identical children wearing identical clothing and you have a rather strange set of events.

Of course you do know what Kate says about coincidences ?

which file is that in?  I haven't heard that before.

[Alfie]

But Shannon Matthews hadn't actually been kidnapped.

Add this to the coincidence that two men were seen in PDL on the 3rd of May, both with identical children wearing identical clothing and you have a rather strange set of events.

Of course you do know what Kate says about coincidences ?

As G-Unit pointed out earlier in this thread there were differences between the two men seen carrying children.  As for the Shannon Matthews case it was a HUGE coincidence that the dogs alerted in the house of the man who was suspected of taking her, particularly as she was still alive at the time, don't you think?

[slartibartfast]

As G-Unit pointed out earlier in this thread there were differences between the two men seen carrying children.  As for the Shannon Matthews case it was a HUGE coincidence that the dogs alerted in the house of the man who was suspected of taking her, particularly as she was still alive at the time, don't you think?

Well they did find the cause.

[Alfie]

Well they did find the cause.

And your point is...?