Mark Williams-Thomas suggests Madeleine woke, wandered and was abducted.

[Brietta]

Follow the evidence and then you will know. Tannerman has been found by SY - he didn't open a window. He carried his child the way he did because she was 2 not nearly 4. Smithman used a different carrying style and many eye witnesses claimed it was Madeleine. SY find the Smiths credible - it was the focus of CW and Tannerman gone. Amaral was going to bring the Smiths back but was removed. The Smiths sighting is the only credible line left in this case. It was from the start for me because he was smart not daft.

The height of the child carried by Smithman was described using as a guide the height of one of the younger Smith children ... who was four.

[stephen25000]

He also gave a description of the ambient lighting in the room which was commensurate with the shutter being raised allowing the gentle street lighting to be seen shining through the curtains.

Really ?

How do we know how the shutters were left prior to the McCann's departing to the Tapas ?

[Robittybob1]

Really ?

How do we know how the shutters were left prior to the McCann's departing to the Tapas ?

Can we be sure they even went to the Tapas Restaurant?

[stephen25000]

Can we be sure they even went to the Tapas Restaurant?

Where you atoms re-assembled incorrectly during your last beaming.

[jassi]

Good questions - why would the McCanns allow another to do the check if they knew Madeleine was deceased in the apartment?  Did they know that at 9:30 or was it at 10:00 that Kate first became aware that Madeleine had died?  (If you accept Amaral's theory that Madeleine had died accidentally)

It could be that by that time, Madeleine wasn't in the apartment, but concealed nearby, so wouldn't be immediately found.

[carlymichelle]

Can we be sure they even went to the Tapas Restaurant?

there is  cctv footage of the tapas so  yes

[Robittybob1]

Were you atoms re-assembled incorrectly during your last beaming.

I was reinforcing your doubts. What is certain?
Stephen () "How do we know how the shutters were left prior to the McCann's departing to the Tapas ?"

[Robittybob1]

there is  cctv footage of the tapas so  yes

No there isn't, not as far as I know.  Cite please.

[Robittybob1]

It could be that by that time, Madeleine wasn't in the apartment, but concealed nearby, so wouldn't be immediately found.

So it was sheer luck that Matt didn't look to see if Madeleine had woke and wandered?

[jassi]

It may be that Madeleine being discovered missing half an hour earlier would have had no effect on how things evolved - except that the group would have gone hungry that night.

[Brietta]

Really ?

How do we know how the shutters were left prior to the McCann's departing to the Tapas ?

A listening check was made at the McCann children's window just after nine (Matthew Oldfield) and the shutters were as they should have been at that time.

[Brietta]

there is  cctv footage of the tapas so  yes

There is no CCTV footage from the tapas restaurant.

[Robittybob1]

It may be that Madeleine being discovered missing half an hour earlier would have had no effect on how things evolved - except that the group would have gone hungry that night.

Were the McCanns disappointed that Matt wasn't the one that discovered Madeleine missing (woke and wandered)  that would have to mean that Gerry was lying and he had noticed Madeleine missing but told no one other than Kate, so she agreed to let Matt check so he could find her missing.  Really does that make any sense at all?  So when in Amarals theory did the McCanns first become aware Madeleine had wandered?

[carlymichelle]

 


now  dont be such a know it all next  time this is a  few hours before maddie vanished

C.C.T.V pictures of Tapas 7 (minus Kate and Gerry McCann) at Paraiso restaurant on 3 May 2007 before the staged abduction began




http://gerrymccan-abuseofpower-humanrights.blogspot.com.au/2009/02/cctv-pictures-of-tapas-7-minus-kate-and.html

[jassi]

A listening check was made at the McCann children's window just after nine (Matthew Oldfield) and the shutters were as they should have been at that time.

Like the door position, how would he know how they should have been?
We don't know how visible the damage was or indeed what the damage was.
Perhaps Matt wouldn't have noticed. He didn't notice Madeleine.