McCanns appeal to the European Court of Human Rights

[Robittybob1]

I think most if us already understand  that... It's called metaphorically speaking... Isn't that obvious

It maybe metaphorically speaking but then they turn that metaphor around and make it a fact.  You would like more weight to be placed on the side of right to a good name.  How do they apply the right amounts of weight to both sides of the scale when the two sides are different.

What they are saying it is more important to have free speech rather than the damage that that free speech causes.

I personally feel that if the claims made by GA affect the search for Madeleine those claims are excessively damaging and the scales should swing the other way.

[Venturi Swirl]

Which question?

You've been back on the highly offensive paedophilia angle again today.
So this time try KISS.

You might just make more progress.

this question

“So how far does the right to free speech extend in Portugal?  Is there anything I can't say or write?  If so does that make Portugal a little bit fascist too?”

How many more times  are you going to ask me “which question”?

[Robittybob1]

You are not making any sense imo

Our = the forum's benefit.

[Mr Gray]

It maybe metaphorically speaking but then they turn that metaphor around and make it a fact.  You would like more weight to be placed on the side of right to a good name.  How do they apply right amounts of weight to both sides of the scale when the two sides are different.

What they are saying it is more important to have free speech rather than the damage than that free speech causes.

I personally feel that if the claims made by GA affect the search for Madeleine those claims are excessively damaging and the scales should swing the other way.

The SC judgement is an opinion.. Nothing more...it's now up to the ECHR to give their interpretation of the law.. They can't rule on the damage to the search

[Mr Gray]

Yes to our benefit.

In what way to the forums benefit... Do you feel harrassing me benefits the forum

[Robittybob1]

The SC judgement is an opinion.. Nothing more...it's now up to the ECHR to give their interpretation of the law.. They can't rule on the damage to the search

Well how do they do that then?  What points did the SC miss that they didn't place enough weight on the side of the right to a good name?

[Mr Gray]

Well how do they do that then?  What points did the SC miss that they didn't place enough weight on the side of the right to a good name?

Read some of the cases I have linked to and you will understand ...why should I waste my time explaining things to you

[Robittybob1]

Well how do they do that then?  What points did the SC miss that they didn't place enough weight on the side of the right to a good name?

I'm tending to think Madeleine is the main person being denied the right to a good name.  Is she dead or alive?

GA claims she is dead when she maybe alive.    Is that denying someone's right to a good name?

[Mr Gray]

I'm tending to think Madeleine is the main person being denied the right to a good name.  Is she dead or alive?

GA claims she is dead when she maybe alive.    Is that denying someone's right to a good name?

Read the articles and you will understand.. After your harrassment of me I've no intention of explaining anything to you

[Robittybob1]

Read some of the cases I have linked to and you will understand ...why should I waste my time explaining things to you

So do you know what makes the difference?

[Mr Gray]

So do you know what makes the difference?

Yes...

[Robittybob1]

In what way to the forums benefit... Do you feel harassing me benefits the forum

You feel harassed.  I feel I'm trying to help you produce a better post, ones without ad hom arguments and opinion as fact.   Progress has been made.  In fact I'm starting to appreciate your posts now.

[Robittybob1]

Yes...

Well can you use words to explain it then please?

[ShiningInLuz]

this question

“So how far does the right to free speech extend in Portugal?  Is there anything I can't say or write?  If so does that make Portugal a little bit fascist too?”

How many more times  are you going to ask me “which question”?

Despite the question marks, I believe that is purely a propaganda statement, so I saw no point in engaging.  I still don't.

[Venturi Swirl]

Despite the question marks, I believe that is purely a propaganda statement, so I saw no point in engaging.  I still don't.

. I knew you’d be unable to answer so thanks for confirming it.