McCanns appeal to the European Court of Human Rights

[G-Unit]

where does that figure come from....what do you mean by upheld......i dont think you understand  the  table at all...you seem totally confused

Applictions are upheld when the court finds a violation.

[Mr Gray]

Applictions are upheld when the court finds a violation.

Portugal had 309 judgements.. Only 13 found no violation.. That's 4%.....one of the worst... Those are the true figures

[G-Unit]

Portugal had 309 judgements.. Only 13 found no violation.. That's 4%.....one of the worst... Those are the true figures

It's not a case of how many cases are upheld in my opinion. Clearly the applications against Portugal were solid ones. Other applications against other countries weren't.

[Mr Gray]

It's not a case of how many cases are upheld in my opinion. Clearly the applications against Portugal were solid ones. Other applications against other countries weren't.

Of course they were solid ones... Because the SC made mistakes... Other countries judiciaries apply European law more accurately... Can't you understand such a simple principle..

[G-Unit]

Of course they were solid ones... Because the SC made mistakes... Other countries judiciaries apply European law more accurately... Can't you understand such a simple principle..

So UK lawyers put forward more of the less solid cases than Portuguese lawyers did.

[Mr Gray]

So UK lawyers put forward more of the less solid cases than Portuguese lawyers did.

It seems you are trying to make up ridiculous excuses fir Portugal's abysmal record at the ECHR.. One thing can't be denied.. Their record is abysmal

[Eleanor]

It seems you are trying to make up ridiculous excuses fir Portugal's abysmal record at the ECHR.. One thing can't be denied.. Their record is abysmal

Amnesty International aren't all that pleased with Portugal either.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Applictions are upheld when the court finds a violation.

However, the EU countries who have signed up can be held account and 'punished' qlthoughm Countries can ignore the findings anyhow.  The UK is now working on its own laws and supreme courts. After some dodgy people were granted legal aid to stay in this country with the blessing of the ECHR. The right to live  VS  the right to kill and murder.

Amnesty International has been hijacked by terrorist groups around the globe.

[Mr Gray]

However, the EU countries who have signed up can be held account and 'punished' qlthoughm Countries can ignore the findings anyhow.  The UK is now working on its own laws and supreme courts. After some dodgy people were granted legal aid to stay in this country with the blessing of the ECHR. The right to live  VS  the right to kill and murder.

Amnesty International has been hijacked by terrorist groups around the globe.

Its not just EU countries who are signed up to the declaration of Human Rights

[barrier]

Amnesty International aren't all that pleased with Portugal either.

Not sure amnesty's flag is one to pin to a mast.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/06/amnesty-international-has-toxic-working-culture-report-finds.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Its not just EU countries who are signed up to the declaration of Human Rights

 


I know that Davel. I have mentioned before, it was the countries of the EU who used it. I believe Russia and a couple of other non EU countries signed up. That is the reason for not wanting EU laws to be paramount to national laws.

[Mr Gray]

 


I know that Davel. I have mentioned before, it was the countries of the EU who used it. I believe Russia and a couple of other non EU countries signed up. That is the reason for not wanting EU laws to be paramount to national laws.

It's more than a couple.. About 20

[slartibartfast]

Amnesty International aren't all that pleased with Portugal either.

Cite?

[Brietta]

Cite?

Sorry I haven't taken the time to read through -  https://algarvedailynews.com/news/15722-amnesty-international-reports-on-portugal-persistent-human-rights-problems  -  there are just so many of them.

I seem to remember one from around 2007 when they expressed some amazement to finding an unusual number of, I think it was baseball bats, during inspections of police stations.

[Eleanor]

Sorry I haven't taken the time to read through -  https://algarvedailynews.com/news/15722-amnesty-international-reports-on-portugal-persistent-human-rights-problems  -  there are just so many of them.

I seem to remember one from around 2007 when they expressed some amazement to finding an unusual number of, I think it was baseball bats, during inspections of police stations.

Thank you, Brietta.  Oh Dear.  Worse than I thought.