Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[Brietta]

I said human cellular samples were collected in areas where the dogs alerted (5A being one example where both dogs alerted). The exact details of the alerts and where samples were taken are in the files released by the PJ and I posted the  links.

As you have indicated ... no point in 'debating' and I have agreed there is no point in a debate based on information you are unable to substantiate for the simple reason it is inaccurate.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

As you have indicated ... no point in 'debating' and I have agreed there is no point in a debate based on information you are unable to substantiate for the simple reason it is inaccurate.

Both dogs marked "an area behind the sofa in the sitting room near the window overlooking the road". (Provided for you in the links earlier - specifically from the PJ Report dated July 31st 2007).

[Brietta]

Both dogs marked "an area behind the sofa in the sitting room near the window overlooking the road". (Provided for you in the links earlier - specifically from the PJ Report dated July 31st 2007).

Human cellular samples springs into memory ... care to nip into the forensic report and detail what was found there.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Human cellular samples springs into memory ... care to nip into the forensic report and detail what was found there.

Why don’t you? I stated that the PJ files confirm that human cellular material was collected from an area where both a blood and cadaver dog alerted. Why is that so hard to accept? It doesn’t implicate any particular suspect. Evidence found there could lend weight to the possibility that a corpse had been present in apartment 5A. If the human cellular material was blood it could have come from one of MM’s nosebleeds that GM reportedly couldn’t remember if she had or not. The British Lab was unable to say if it was blood or other human cellular material not was DNA analysis conclusive . All the more reason for further testing imo. It might turn up a vital link to the German sex offender.

[pathfinder73]

Both dogs alerting in the same place is significant to the police regardless of what naysayers think!

[Erngath]

Both dogs alerting in the same place is significant to the police regardless of what naysayers think!

Significant to which police?

[Venturi Swirl]

Significant to which police?

Pathfinder hasn’t realised it’s not 2007 anymore.

[pathfinder73]

Significant to which police?

Significant to any police in an unsolved case.

[Venturi Swirl]

Significant to any police in an unsolved case.

German police don’t seem too interested.

[Brietta]

Why don’t you? I stated that the PJ files confirm that human cellular material was collected from an area where both a blood and cadaver dog alerted. Why is that so hard to accept? It doesn’t implicate any particular suspect. Evidence found there could lend weight to the possibility that a corpse had been present in apartment 5A. If the human cellular material was blood it could have come from one of MM’s nosebleeds that GM reportedly couldn’t remember if she had or not. The British Lab was unable to say if it was blood or other human cellular material nor was DNA analysis conclusive . All the more reason for further testing imo. It might turn up a vital link to the German sex offender.

I have read the files.  Apparently you have not or you would be capable of providing a cite to back up your claims re "cellular material".  I await with little interest to see on exactly what you are basing your assertions.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Significant to any police in an unsolved case.

Operation Grange is shameful for not considering the alerts and pushing for a new analysis of the human cellular material found where the dogs alerted.

[Venturi Swirl]

Operation Grange is shameful for not considering the alerts and pushing for a new analysis of the human cellular material found where the dogs alerted.

What was stopping the Portuguese investigation doing that?

[Brietta]

What was stopping the Portuguese investigation doing that?

As we were onetime constantly told ... 'this is a Portuguese investigation.  The PJ have primacy.'  Interesting times with the advent of the Germans.

[Mr Gray]

Operation Grange is shameful for not considering the alerts and pushing for a new analysis of the human cellular material found where the dogs alerted.

SY understand the value of the alerts...zero

[Brietta]

SY understand the value of the alerts...zero

Even Sandra Felgueiras  understood the value of them when she read the released files and realised she had been fed a pack of lies about the dogs and much else.  She wasn't best pleased.