Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[barrier]

Perhaps that's why he ignored the car until being called back

The problem with that being?

[Mr Gray]

The problem with that being?

The problem being that in Grimes statement he says in passing the car the dog showed a particular interest in it... He didn't... He ignored it.. What's your explanation

[barrier]

https://www.murderscience.com/articles/2018/1/29/cadaver-dogs-

Another paper with an interesting conclusion.

http://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1024&context=ant_facpub

[barrier]

The problem being that in Grimes statement he says in passing the car the dog showed a particular interest in it... He didn't... He ignored it.. What's your explanation

Still don't understand your issue.

[Mr Gray]

Still don't understand your issue.

No problem... I'm sure others, do... Hers the actual quote..


When passing a
vehicle I now know to be hired and in the possession of the McCann family,
the dog's behaviour changed substantially.

[barrier]

No problem... I'm sure others, do... Hers the actual quote..


When passing a
vehicle I now know to be hired and in the possession of the McCann family,
the dog's behaviour changed substantially.

Ok,lets try another way,are there set parameters that a dog handler must adhere to,if so can you post it to let us cross reference and see where the issue is.

[Mr Gray]

Ok,lets try another way,are there set parameters that a dog handler must adhere to,if so can you post it to let us cross reference and see where the issue is.

My issue is Grimes statement doesn't tally with the facts... I'm sure that's a reasonable explanation I just can't see it

[G-Unit]

The problem being that in Grimes statement he says in passing the car the dog showed a particular interest in it... He didn't... He ignored it.. What's your explanation

So Grime's opinion is that the dog's behavour changed significantly as he passed the McCann's hire car. Your opinion is that it didn't. Grime spent years training and working with Eddie, so we can assume he would notice things that might not be obvious or significant to others. Others like you, for example.

[Mr Gray]

So Grime's opinion is that the dog's behavour changed significantly as he passed the McCann's hire car. Your opinion is that it didn't. Grime spent years training and working with Eddie, so we can assume he would notice things that might not be obvious or significant to others. Others like you, for example.

That's your explanation... It doesn't really fit imo.
The dog simply toddled straight past the, car showing no interest at all... And needed to be called back.. Have you watched the video

[Mr Gray]

So Grime's opinion is that the dog's behavour changed significantly as he passed the McCann's hire car. Your opinion is that it didn't. Grime spent years training and working with Eddie, so we can assume he would notice things that might not be obvious or significant to others. Others like you, for example.

Yet Grine didn't notice all the posters of Maddie on the car... Strange isn't it

[G-Unit]

Yet Grine didn't notice all the posters of Maddie on the car... Strange isn't it

He approached the car from the front. How many posters were there and were there any on the windscreen?

[Mr Gray]

He approached the car from the front. How many posters were there and were there any on the windscreen?

He said he.. Now knows.... Must have seen the posters at the time. 

[Mr Gray]

Being considered an expert is no guarantee of anything... We should still question .
Look at all those experts telling people to stay in their burning apartments in Grenfell

[pathfinder73]

That's your explanation... It doesn't really fit imo.
The dog simply toddled straight past the, car showing no interest at all... And needed to be called back.. Have you watched the video

The video clearly shows what happens. A little summary:

52:22 - MG calling Eddie back to a car

52:32 - MG calling Eddie back to the next car

53:12 - Eddie's behaviour changes at the hire car and he is then seen chasing a scent. MG now starts to investigate the source of that scent. Eddie positively alerts at the hire car.

[Mr Gray]

The video clearly shows what happens. A little summary:

52:22 - MG calling Eddie back to a car

52:32 - MG calling Eddie back to the next car

53:12 - Eddie's behaviour changes at the hire car and he is then seen chasing a scent. MG now starts to investigate the source of that scent. Eddie positively alerts at the hire car.

Yes thanks for that.  .the video I posted clearly shows eddie passing the car with no change in behaviour... Then being called back... Perhaps it's the act of calling back that triggers the alert..