Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[G-Unit]

Strange how OG are looking at abduction then isn't it?    The fact that Madeleine is missing and has not been found is evidence of abduction.

It's also evidence of death and a successful body disposal.

[Lace]

It's also evidence of death and a successful body disposal.

It has been proven there was no way the McCann's could have disposed of Madeleine's body.   Give me a good example of how they did it.

[G-Unit]

It has been proven there was no way the McCann's could have disposed of Madeleine's body.   Give me a good example of how they did it.

Proven how?

[Mr Gray]

I'm not mathematically inclined, so calculating probabilities isn't my thing.

I'm sure you understand the words likely or unlikely... Which one do you think it is

[G-Unit]

I'm sure you understand the words likely or unlikely... Which one do you think it is

I say again, I don't know what happened that night. Two possibilities rely on what the parents and their friends said. The parents dismissed woke and wandered, but that was just their opinion. They proposed a stranger abduction immediately, but they and their friends were the source of any evidence pointing at that possibility. There is very little independant evidence of what happened.

[Mr Gray]

I say again, I don't know what happened that night. Two possibilities rely on what the parents and their friends said. The parents dismissed woke and wandered, but that was just their opinion. They proposed a stranger abduction immediately, but they and their friends were the source of any evidence pointing at that possibility. There is very little independant evidence of what happened.

The archiving report by the PJ said woke and wandered was highly unlikeley. Based on everything we know i think its highly unlikely the parents were involved...there is no real evidence against the parents  according to the PJ...and it seems SY and the German police are investigating an abduction.

[G-Unit]

The archiving report by the PJ said woke and wandered was highly unlikeley. Based on everything we know i think its highly unlikely the parents were involved...there is no real evidence against the parents  according to the PJ...and it seems SY and the German police are investigating an abduction.

There's no 'real' evidence against anyone imo. All the evidence is weak.

[Brietta]

I say again, I don't know what happened that night. Two possibilities rely on what the parents and their friends said. The parents dismissed woke and wandered, but that was just their opinion. They proposed a stranger abduction immediately, but they and their friends were the source of any evidence pointing at that possibility. There is very little independant evidence of what happened.

The witness statements made are evidence are they not?

[Brietta]

There's no 'real' evidence against anyone imo. All the evidence is weak.

                            In your opinion.

[Mr Gray]

There's no 'real' evidence against anyone imo. All the evidence is weak.

there is evidence the parents are not involved...and no real evidence they are

[G-Unit]

The witness statements made are evidence are they not?

Indeed, but statements aren't necessarily true.

[Mr Gray]

Indeed, but statements aren't necessarily true.

The investigators have to decide who they beleive is telling the truth...it seems they have decided the McCanns are.
there is nothing to suggest they are lying.

[Brietta]

Indeed, but statements aren't necessarily true.

That is for the police to investigate and co-ordinate.  It is called 'detective work' or something like that and it must be considered that the Judicial Police did that with the dog indications and having done so decided to discard them as evidence.  Read all about it in their final report.

[G-Unit]

The investigators have to decide who they beleive is telling the truth...it seems they have decided the McCanns are.
there is nothing to suggest they are lying.

Investigator's opinions can't be kept out of investigations, but they still need to back them up using evidence. OG have offered no evidence whatsoever to support their opinion that the parents are telling the truth. Simon Foy tried by saying "they were where they were" when Madeleine disappeared. He seems to have overlooked the fact that the time of the disappearance is unknown.

[Mr Gray]

Investigator's opinions can't be kept out of investigations, but they still need to back them up using evidence. OG have offered no evidence whatsoever to support their opinion that the parents are telling the truth. Simon Foy tried by saying "they were where they were" when Madeleine disappeared. He seems to have overlooked the fact that the time of the disappearance is unknown.

They arr experienced and it seems based on their experience they believe the mccanns are telling the truth.
It's the same with many crimes.  There's no hard evidence the Needhans are not complicit in Bens disappearance... We only have their word... And in the circumstances that's enough