Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[The General]

You totally underestimate me....if hes proven right i would congratulate him....but not  afat chance in hell of that happening......according to the evidence

poor sod you say...I  partly agree with that

Yep, the attempted character assassination was out of order. He was just a guy doing his job.
Incredibly unreliable? It's not Russell Grant churning out horoscopes.

[Mr Gray]

Yep, the attempted character assassination was out of order. He was just a guy doing his job.
Incredibly unreliable? It's not Russell Grant churning out horoscopes.

i have compared what I see as  a scattergun approach to the likes of Russel so you are doing better. Any professional must accept criticism and be poreared to answer it

[The General]

i have compared what I see as  a scattergun approach to the likes of Russel so you are doing better. Any professional must accept criticism and be poreared to answer it

So EVRD dog use is the same as Astrology?

[Mr Gray]

So EVRD dog use is the same as Astrology?

Read the post

[The General]

Read the post

I did. You compared EVRD use to astrology.

[Mr Gray]

I did. You compared EVRD use to astrology.

No I didn't

[The General]

No I didn't

Yeh yer did, kid. And I always knew you would double down one day.
I'm not panicking, I'm ambivalent to mildly interested.

[Mr Gray]

Yeh yer did, kid. And I always knew you would double down one day.
I'm not panicking, I'm ambivalent to mildly interested.

I compared that in my opinion Grime had a scattergun approach which reminded me of stage psychics and astrology...

[The General]

I compared that in my opinion Grime had a scattergun approach which reminded me of stage psychics and astrology...

Same. You're suggesting both are fraudulent.

[Mr Gray]

Same. You're suggesting both are fraudulent.

I've never suggested Grime was fraudulent....

[kizzy]

if it is shown that maddie died elsewhere and not in the apartment...what will that do for the credibility of Grime and his dogs. The dogs taht alerted so many times and only to things associated with the McCanns...in an apartment where no one else has died

Well at the moment that is the only evidence there is...The apartment.

[The General]

I've never suggested Grime was fraudulent....

By comparing his approach to that of an astrologer or a stage psychic you are doing exactly that.
Unless you're comparing his method in a favourable light, as you believe astrology and stage psychics to be bona fide and genuine.

[Mr Gray]

Same. You're suggesting both are fraudulent.

If you can't see the target...taking s scattergun approach gives s good chance of hitting it...reasonable not fraudulent..of course if theres no target you won't hit it

[Mr Gray]

By comparing his approach to that of an astrologer or a stage psychic you are doing exactly that.
Unless you're comparing his method in a favourable light, as you believe astrology and stage psychics to be bona fide and genuine.

If you read my post above you will understand. Grime is using a reasonable tecnique to hit a target...the astrologer isnt

[The General]

If you can't see the target...taking s scattergun approach gives s good chance of hitting it...reasonable not fraudulent..of course if theres no target you won't hit it

The inference being that there's no scientific merit behind what he's doing, and he knows it.
And for him to get the dogs to alert only amongst the McCann possessions and their apartment / car, etc, he therefore manipulates them in some manner.

You've pinned your colours to the mast this time.