Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[Venturi Swirl]

Right there with Morse and Grime, as you would know if you read the link I provided.

I don’t read every link and I wasn’t asking you.

[Venturi Swirl]

It's less than 48 hours, isn't it?

There's a man in prison and Morse's evidence helped to put him there. Closer to home there's another man in prison and another cadaver dog's alerts helped to put him there. Cadaver dog alerts can and have been used in cases where no body can be found.

Yes, like the case of the Swedish serial killer who never was, put in prison by a faulty cadaver dog called Zampo.

[Eleanor]

It's less than 48 hours, isn't it?

There's a man in prison and Morse's evidence helped to put him there. Closer to home there's another man in prison and another cadaver dog's alerts helped to put him there. Cadaver dog alerts can and have been used in cases where no body can be found.

And Cadaver Dogs have been known to be wrong.  If the day ever comes when Convictions rely on Dogs then Justice will be over.

[G-Unit]

And Cadaver Dogs have been known to be wrong.  If the day ever comes when Convictions rely on Dogs then Justice will be over.

They are perfectly acceptable as part of a body of circumstantial evidence imo. Forensic scientists and medical experts have been known to be wrong too.

[Mr Gray]

They are perfectly acceptable as part of a body of circumstantial evidence imo. Forensic scientists and medical experts have been known to be wrong too.

They have almost never been acceptable in UK courts.....and every UK expert apart from Grime it seems accepts this. perhaps tahts why he was invited to the US....because his view seems out of line with accepted opinion

[barrier]

And Cadaver Dogs have been known to be wrong.  If the day ever comes when Convictions rely on Dogs then Justice will be over.

If a cadaver dog were to find Madeleine's remains on land once frequented/owned by this German suspect would you accept that.

[Mr Gray]

If a cadaver dog were to find Madeleine's remains on land once frequented/owned by this German suspect would you accept that.

the alert would then be corroborated by physical evidence

[Eleanor]

If a cadaver dog were to find Madeleine's remains on land once frequented/owned by this German suspect would you accept that.

I don't think they need Cadaver Dogs for this.  They need to climb down very deep wells and haul out any Bones.

As for a grave then give me a shout.  My Dachshund will find it for free.  Rotten Little Swine.

[Venturi Swirl]

I don't think they need Cadaver Dogs for this.  They need to climb down very deep wells and haul out any Bones.

As for a grave then give me a shout.  My Dachshund will find it for free.  Rotten Little Swine.

They should lower Morse into every well on a harness or hold him over the well and if he barks they can investigate further.  If he doesn’t then it 100% means no body was ever put down there.  It would save a lot of time and effort.

[faithlilly]

They have almost never been acceptable in UK courts.....and every UK expert apart from Grime it seems accepts this. perhaps tahts why he was invited to the US....because his view seems out of line with accepted opinion

Michael Stone....absolutely no eye witness evidence or forensics to tie him to the murder he was convicted of. The case was purely circumstantial.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Yes, like the case of the Swedish serial killer who never was, put in prison by a faulty cadaver dog called Zampo.

You need to go back and read the detail of that case. None of the Police trained dogs gave false alerts... Zampo didn’t have Eddie’s credentials.

[Mr Gray]

Michael Stone....absolutely no eye witness evidence or forensics to tie him to the murder he was convicted of. The case was purely circumstantial.

According to what we read in the press and TV. It would be interesting to see the evidence he  was convicted on...was it just his alleged confession to another prisoner....more evidence against CB it would seem.

[Eleanor]

You need to go back and read the detail of that case. None of the Police trained dogs gave false alerts... Zampo didn’t have Eddie’s credentials.

What Credentials?  Eddie wasn't even Licensed.

[Venturi Swirl]

You need to go back and read the detail of that case. None of the Police trained dogs gave false alerts... Zampo didn’t have Eddie’s credentials.

Zampo was a trained cadaver dog that put an inncoent man in jail, no?

[Venturi Swirl]

What about the trained police cadaver dog that was shown on tv recently alerting to a dead chick and rewarded for doing so by his trainer?  What was that all about?