Strange Witness Statements

[Benice]

They were the last people who claimed to have done so.

Until proven otherwise, THAT REMAINS THE CASE.

Unless of course you believe in fantasies,

When have they ever claimed to be the last people to see her alive?   As you are putting this 'claim' forward as something significant and factual - then you need to back it up with evidence.

[stephen25000]

When have they ever claimed to be the last people to see her alive?   As you are putting this 'claim' forward as something significant and factual - then you need to back it up with evidence.

You really show a lack of comprehension.

What evidence is there anyone else saw Madeleine.

CITE the evidence.

[G-Unit]

When have they ever claimed to be the last people to see her alive?   As you are putting this 'claim' forward as something significant and factual - then you need to back it up with evidence.

They both saw her before they went to the restaurant and then Gerald had his 'proud father' moment in the apartment later. As far as I know she hasn't been seen since.

[faithlilly]

They both saw her before they went to the restaurant and then Gerald had his 'proud father' moment in the apartment later. As far as I know she hasn't been seen since.

Odd that Gerry could see Madeleine with her blanket and cuddlecat, to have his 'proud father' moment,  with the shutters shut yet Kate couldn't when the shutters were allegedly open and there was more light in the room.

[Angelo222]

Does anyone else think it strange that Madeleine and the twins slept soundly on the Thursday night yet she and Sean cried and cried the previous two nights?  What changed?

[Benice]

You really show a lack of comprehension.

What evidence is there anyone else saw Madeleine.

CITE the evidence.

Your usual 'deflection'  tactics, which you always resort to when you can't provide evidence to back up your claims, are duly noted.



 

[stephen25000]

Your usual 'deflection'  tactics, which you always resort to when you can't provide evidence to back up your claims, are duly noted.

Par for the course reply benice.

Try reading the other posters comments as well.

You need to get out in the real world, and realize life is not about just supporting the mccanns.

[G-Unit]

Does anyone else think it strange that Madeleine and the twins slept soundly on the Thursday night yet she and Sean cried and cried the previous two nights?  What changed?

Well, the McCanns either denied or played down the earlier crying, and suspected that sedation might have played a part on the Thursday, apparently.

[jassi]

As there were 5 experienced doctors in the group, they ought to have been able to decide whether or not the remaining 2 children had been sedated.

[pathfinder73]

Dear Mr Bennett,

I can confirm that whatever information I had (including some photos of my sons taken on the day Madeleine disappeared, which showed her in the background) was passed both to the police and to the McCanns at the time.

Philip Edmonds





http://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t3471-would-this-account-for-the-unprecedented-high-level-of-political-support

[Lace]

Does anyone else think it strange that Madeleine and the twins slept soundly on the Thursday night yet she and Sean cried and cried the previous two nights?  What changed?

In my opinion it was later on the Tuesday night that the children cried,   Kate said Amelie woke crying and woke Sean and Madeleine,  it was about 12 o'clock.

In my opinion it was Amelie who woke first,  then Sean woke and cried followed by Madeleine shouting 'Daddy'  I think it was this night that Madeleine was talking about when she said 'why didn't you come when me and Sean cried'.     I don't think Madeleine said 'when Sean and me cried last night'   did she as Kate and Gerry were trying to think when they had cried.

Children get confused and Madeleine could have meant the Tuesday night episode as it was the only time Sean and Madeleine were woken up.

[G-Unit]

In my opinion it was later on the Tuesday night that the children cried,   Kate said Amelie woke crying and woke Sean and Madeleine,  it was about 12 o'clock.

In my opinion it was Amelie who woke first,  then Sean woke and cried followed by Madeleine shouting 'Daddy'  I think it was this night that Madeleine was talking about when she said 'why didn't you come when me and Sean cried'.     I don't think Madeleine said 'when Sean and me cried last night'   did she as Kate and Gerry were trying to think when they had cried.

Children get confused and Madeleine could have meant the Tuesday night episode as it was the only time Sean and Madeleine were woken up.

A nice story with nothing at all to support it however.

[Alfred R Jones]

A nice story with nothing at all to support it however.

Pathfinder has spun a few not-so-nice stories with nothing to support them either - I don't see you criticising him or her!   &%+((£

[pathfinder73]

Pathfinder has spun a few not-so-nice stories with nothing to support them either - I don't see you criticising him or her!   &%+((£

The Oldfields said they heard no crying and they were next door to the children's room. Matt stayed in on the Sunday and Rachael on the Wednesday and neither heard crying. On the Thursday the twins didn't wake up all night with all the screaming and noise in the apartment. Pamela Fenn heard crying on the Tuesday. If people can't account for their time and what they were doing and when they refused to do a reconstruction to clear up all these unanswered questions it's their problem not mine.

[Alfred R Jones]

The Oldfields said they heard no crying and they were next door to the children's room. Matt stayed in on the Sunday and Rachael on the Wednesday and neither heard crying. On the Thursday the twins didn't wake up all night with all the screaming and noise in the apartment. Pamela Fenn heard crying on the Tuesday. If people can't account for their time and what they were doing and when they refused to do a reconstruction to clear up all these unanswered questions it's their problem not mine.

That's fine, you just carry on making up your stories, I'm sure no one minds at all.