Sceptics beliefs ?

[Mr Gray]

I'm not going to choose between 'cadaver dofs are reliable' and 'cadaver dogs are unreliable' just because you think those are the only choices. Gerry McCann used that simplistic approach and ended up looking silly imo

I don't complain to mods. 

I have no objection to discussing with you, but I won't be told what I think or what I should think. That's not discussion imo.

There are only two choices..... The alerts are either reliable or not..... If they are reliable sometimes but not others then by definition they are unreliable... Where did rob get the request that you had, asked me to stop hassling you

[G-Unit]

You just told Davel what he thinks, how very dare you!

I dare because he told me what he thinks;
snip/
Either the alerts are a reliable indicators or they are not
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520904#msg520904

[Mr Gray]

I dare because he told me what he thinks;
snip/
Either the alerts are a reliable indicators or they are not
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520904#msg520904

That's perfectly true... They can't be reliable sometimes and not others.... That makes then unreliable making Gerry perfectly correct

[Mr Gray]

I dare because he told me what he thinks;
snip/
Either the alerts are a reliable indicators or they are not
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520904#msg520904

And you have told me what you think on several occasions

[Venturi Swirl]

I dare because he told me what he thinks;
snip/
Either the alerts are a reliable indicators or they are not
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520904#msg520904

What other options are there then?

[Miss Taken Identity]

None of us care about what someone else thinks.

Well that isn't entirly true is it... not long ago people who didn't buy into team McCann story were called and referred to as evil trolls.. so some do care.

 They cared enough to hound a woman with an opinion heaven forbid! RIP Brenda.

[Mr Gray]

Well that isn't entirly true is it... not long ago people who didn't buy into team McCann story were called and referred to as evil trolls.. so some do care.

 They cared enough to hound a woman with an opinion heaven forbid! RIP Brenda.

What an absolute travesty of the truth

[G-Unit]

There are only two choices..... The alerts are either reliable or not..... If they are reliable sometimes but not others then by definition they are unreliable... Where did rob get the request that you had, asked me to stop hassling you

You are entitled to believe what you wish. You're not entitled to impose your beliefs on me. Are you accusing me of lying when I said I don't report people to mods?

[Mr Gray]

You are entitled to believe what you wish. You're not entitled to impose your beliefs on me. Are you accusing me of lying when I said I don't report people to mods?

What I said clearly was... Where did rob get the idea from that you had asked me to stop harassing you.. If you didn't ask him where did he get it from... Perhaps rob could answer

[Mr Gray]

G-unit has asked you to stop hassling her.  Please respect that request.

Could you point out where gunit has asked me to stop hassling her.... Or remove the accusations

[G-Unit]

Could you point out where gunit has asked me to stop hassling her.... Or remove the accusations

Perhaps he read this post? It was addressed to you, and you were badgering me for a firm opinion. 

For those harrassing me for a firm opinion, here's one. Gerry McCann was very foolish to make that sweeping statement.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520871#msg520871

[Robittybob1]

That's perfectly true... They can't be reliable sometimes and not others.... That makes then unreliable making Gerry perfectly correct

If the reliability is in order of 95%, I'd accept there are times they alert incorrectly but correctly 95% of the time.  I don't accept the small number of incorrect responses allows for Eddie and Keela to be described as unreliable.

[Mr Gray]

Perhaps he read this post? It was addressed to you, and you were badgering me for a firm opinion. 

For those harrassing me for a firm opinion, here's one. Gerry McCann was very foolish to make that sweeping statement.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg520871#msg520871

So where are you asking me to stop hassling you.... You didn't.... Glad, we've got that clear

[Robittybob1]

Could you point out where gunit has asked me to stop hassling her.... Or remove the accusations

I read that from what she was saying in her posts to you.

[Mr Gray]

If the reliability is in order of 95%, I'd accept there are times they alert incorrectly but correctly 95% of the time.  I don't accept the small number of incorrect responses allows for Eddie and Keela to be described as unreliable.

You would need to a be a lot more precise in your wording.. I presume you mean a, test such as carpet squares....that's, a very easy test... You cannot extrapolate those figures to a completely different situation...