I can only comment on the conversations I have had with my friends as I said but I absolutely agree that Labour has lost their historical support in Scotland and tbh without that support it will be hard for the party to regain power in the whole of the U.K. I’d would be interested to know if your husband and his family voted Labour in the last election and if not why not ?
Some of his family would never ever vote for anything other than Labour and I presume they did because to vote Tory would be an anathema to them but others chose to vote SNP.
My two brothers in-law who were both die hard labour voters voted SNP.
And sorry but Jeremy was a vote loser here.
I actually do believe that if the Scottish Labour party did break the ties with the UK Labour party they would fare much better.
How many labour members of Holyrood are there?
Does that not negate your answer that Labour has lost their historical vote n Scotland?
I believe many labour supporters voted SNP because they want an independent Scotland.