Is there a plausible, logical theory of abduction?

[G-Unit]

Did he ever venture an alternative theory?  No.

He never gave any theory. He said there was an opportunity in the timeline for Madeleine to be abducted. He said she could have died in the apartment. More ideas than theories imo.

[Robittybob1]

He never gave any theory. He said there was an opportunity in the timeline for Madeleine to be abducted. He said she could have died in the apartment. More ideas than theories imo.

Interesting idea.  When is an idea just an idea and when does it become a theory?  A theory of abduction needs to be something that accounts for all the intelligence.

[Alfie]

He never gave any theory. He said there was an opportunity in the timeline for Madeleine to be abducted. He said she could have died in the apartment. More ideas than theories imo.

Did he venture any alternative "ideas" then, such as woke and wandered?  Because all I've heard from Op Grange supports the view that they are investigating a criminal act by a stranger.  There is nothing (apart from the lack of an acknowledgment in the McCann Christmas message - lol) to suggest they are pursuing any other "ideas".

[Mr Gray]

He never gave any theory. He said there was an opportunity in the timeline for Madeleine to be abducted. He said she could have died in the apartment. More ideas than theories imo.

which confirms that they think an abduction was possible

[ferryman]

Did he venture any alternative "ideas" then, such as woke and wandered?  Because all I've heard from Op Grange supports the view that they are investigating a criminal act by a stranger.  There is nothing (apart from the lack of an acknowledgment in the McCann Christmas message - lol) to suggest they are pursuing any other "ideas".

My understanding, too.

[faithlilly]

Did he venture any alternative "ideas" then, such as woke and wandered?  Because all I've heard from Op Grange supports the view that they are investigating a criminal act by a stranger.  There is nothing (apart from the lack of an acknowledgment in the McCann Christmas message - lol) to suggest they are pursuing any other "ideas".

There  is nothing since DCI Wall was apponted to suggest what theory they are pursuing. She has remained remarkably tight lipped as have the PJ over the two or so years, no appeals, no updated age progression photos of Madeleine, in fact nothing to suggest what their thinking is.

[G-Unit]

which confirms that they think an abduction was possible

Of course it was, but not the only possibility as some like to insist

[Alfie]

There  is nothing since DCI Wall was apponted to suggest what theory they are pursuing. She has remained remarkably tight lipped as have the PJ over the two or so years, no appeals, no updated age progression photos of Madeleine, in fact nothing to suggest what their thinking is.

So you agree then - nothing whatsoever to suggest the parents are suspects.

[faithlilly]

So you agree then - nothing whatsoever to suggest the parents are suspects.

Nothing to suggest which way she's taking the investigation.

I've heard it said time and time again by supporters that after Amaral Rebelo took the investigation in a completely different direction so why are you so loath to believe that DCI Wall couldn't or hasn't done the same?

[Alfie]

Nothing to suggest which way she's taking the investigation.

I've heard it said time and time again by supporters that after Amaral Rebelo took the investigation in a completely different direction so why are you so loath to believe that DCI Wall couldn't or hasn't done the same?

A different direction?  I thought you were absolutely convinced that Redwood had the mcCanns in his "crosshairs" and that Crimewatch was his coup de theatre designed to secretly let them know that he was on to them!

[faithlilly]

A different direction?  I thought you were absolutely convinced that Redwood had the mcCanns in his "crosshairs" and that Crimewatch was his coup de theatre designed to secretly let them know that he was on to them!

I'm looking at it from your point of view.

[Alfie]

I'm looking at it from your point of view.

so looking at it from your point of view, the parents have always been suspects as far as Andy Redwood and Operation Grange have been concerned, even when they were investigating sex attacks and interviewing PT nationals in PdL, right?  %&5%£

[faithlilly]

so looking at it from your point of view, the parents have always been suspects as far as Andy Redwood and Operation Grange have been concerned, even when they were investigating sex attacks and interviewing PT nationals in PdL, right?  %&5%£

Is that what DCI Wall is doing?

[jassi]

so looking at it from your point of view, the parents have always been suspects as far as Andy Redwood and Operation Grange have been concerned, even when they were investigating sex attacks and interviewing PT nationals in PdL, right?  %&5%£

Probably checking each and every possibility however tenuous so they can't be accused of negligence by armchair judges

[Alfie]

Is that what DCI Wall is doing?

What, this? %&5%£