"no evidence" to support a theory missing girl Madeleine McCann is alive

[jassi]

Don't you think she would have some distant memories of another family?  She might see the photo of the girl with the eye defect and think that is remarkably similar to my own.

Again you make the assumption that she is in a position to do that.
She may have no access to anything in the outside world.
She may have had no education - be unable to read or write

[xtina]

Again you make the assumption that she is in a position to do that.
She may have no access to anything in the outside world.
She may have had no education - be unable to read or write

Or still nearly four years old...in a place,..... she will never be found...

[Snowgirl]

Don't you think she would have some distant memories of another family?  She might see the photo of the girl with the eye defect and think that is remarkably similar to my own.

You're simply  dreaming all kinds of things up .
  Realistically speaking,  where do you  suggest she might see a photo of herself ?

[Snowgirl]

In my thinking the window was opened by some guys attempting to burgle the place.  Madeleine ran out when someone entered by the patio door.  She couldn't get into the Tapas area as someone had shut the door at the secondary reception, and then was picked up from the car park opposite.

She stopped to close the gate behind her too  she was that much in a hurry and didn't let out any of the screams her paternal grandmother  said she could ?

[Venturi Swirl]

You're simply  dreaming all kinds of things up .
  Realistically speaking,  where do you  suggest she might see a photo of herself ?

Front page of a newspaper?  Cover of a book?  Youtube?

[jassi]

Front page of a newspaper?  Cover of a book?  Youtube?

You know that she has access to any of this?

[Eleanor]

You know that she has access to any of this?

It might take some time.

[Venturi Swirl]

You know that she has access to any of this?

Don't be daft.  It was a hypothetical situation, where a girl is abducted to live with a loving family wasn't it?  Are you saying such a child in such a situation would not see books, papers or the internet and would never have heard about Madeleine McCann?

[jassi]

Don't be daft.  It was a hypothetical situation, where a girl is abducted to live with a loving family wasn't it?  Are you saying such a child in such a situation would not see books, papers or the internet and would never have heard about Madeleine McCann?

The thread title mentions nothing about a 'loving family' This is just a supporter fantasy -IMO

[Snowgirl]

Don't be daft.  It was a hypothetical situation, where a girl is abducted to live with a loving family wasn't it?  Are you saying such a child in such a situation would not see books, papers or the internet and would never have heard about Madeleine McCann?

  In which country do you imagine this child is  living ? If not an English speaking country  she will be  speaking a foreign language, so  do you imagine foreign  newspapers will carry news about her ?   
As pointed out previously  if  a family is holding an abducted child , that's illegal  so they won't want her in  any  situations  where she might find out about herself  anyway?  Imo 

[Brietta]

Reasonable choice Rob,but what burglars? SY interviewed the 3 amigos and lost interest in them later on.

You know this how?

Last I heard was that much as Scotland Yard might have wished to follow through on further interviews with the three burglars ... it was not allowed.

If you know differently please post a link to inform the forum of what is going on.


Snip
It's claimed they have been identified as suspects by British police, but officers are being blocked from accessing them by Portuguese cops who say no new evidence has been brought forward.

An officer told the paper: 'It has dogged the investigation all the way through and it's happening again.

'If we can't question the three suspects again the trail goes cold and the case will be shelved.'

When they were previously interviewed, the men admitted theft from apartments at the complex but denied any involvement in the youngster's disappearance.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3564019/Madeleine-McCann-kidnapped-botched-burglary-gang-thieves-British-police-quizzed-blocked-questioning-again.html

[barrier]

Ye gods how many times does it need to be posted.
Taken from Mark Rowleys statement back in April 2017,

The team has looked at in excess of 600 individuals who were identified as being potentially significant to the disappearance. In 2013 the team identified four individuals they declared to be suspects in the case. This led to interviews at a police station in Faro facilitated by the local Policia Judiciária and the search of a large area of wasteland which is close to Madeleine's apartment in Praia Da Luz. The enquiries did not find any evidence to further implicate the individuals in the disappearance and so they are no longer subject of further investigation.

[Venturi Swirl]

  In which country do you imagine this child is  living ? If not an English speaking country  she will be  speaking a foreign language, so  do you imagine foreign  newspapers will carry news about her ?   
As pointed out previously  if  a family is holding an abducted child , that's illegal  so they won't want her in  any  situations  where she might find out about herself  anyway?  Imo

I think Madeleine is likely dead, but if she was taken by someone to live in their family and raised in a caring environment there would come a time when she would be independent and beyond their control so it would be possible that she could encounter pictures or footage of her younger self.

[Robittybob1]

Now back to reality.....

If that had been the case....

It would have been one of the twins...imo

Not if the family had just lost a three year old.  Replace like with like.

[Robittybob1]

Reasonable choice Rob,but what burglars? SY interviewed the 3 amigos and lost interest in them later on.

The burglars just opened the window, they didn't take MM in my theory.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10243.msg495479#msg495479  suggests something similar IMO.