Is Luke Mitchell guilty - your views

[justsaying]

Or an indication of psychopathy

Says Doctor Stephanie, who totally ignores the psychology evaluation saying that he did not have such issues!

[justsaying]

What's the answer then?

Go back and read them so you can completely ignore them again!

[Nicholas]

I agree Jixy - there was no evidence of him peeing in bottles before he found the body of his murdered girlfriend, I think this supports a reaction to trauma. We do not know which way we would react, even as adults. He needed help and support and was failed in more ways than one.

What size were the bottles seized by police and how long do you think it took LM to fill?

[justsaying]

What size were the bottles seized by police and how long do you think it took LM to fill?

 

[jixy]

"Even more worryingly, he also acquired a fascination with knives. His older brother, Shane, had a knife collection and Mitchell gathered his own array. At a party six weeks before killing Jones, he repeatedly jabbed her in the leg with a knife he had been using to cut up cannabis.

Although she was clearly devoted to Mitchell, Jones was not his only girlfriend. He had also been seeing at least two other girls and may even have been grooming them to see which would make the most suitable victim.

One of them was Kara van Nuil, now 17, who met him at army cadets in 2003. He wooed her with romantic text messages but their relationship ended abruptly after he followed her into the cadet hut one night, crept up on her, put his arm around her neck and placed a knife to her throat. Later he tried to laugh it off but van Nuil had been terrified. One month later he killed Jodi Jones.

Another of Mitchell’s girlfriends was 15-year-old Kimberley Thomson, from Kenmore, Perthshire who he had been seeing for about a year before the murder. They had met while he was on holiday and kept in touch. Her resemblance to Jones was uncanny.

Mitchell had arranged to go and stay with Thomson for a fortnight shortly after school broke up. At some point, he was going to have to break this news to Jones.

Dobbie said: "There is a potential Jodi found out about Luke’s planned holiday with Kimberley that Monday. I think he told her at lunchtime."

Not actually true though is it seeing as the holiday was cancelled and Luke had no means to plan/see her whatsoever

[jixy]

We aren't discussing ALL people!

ALL people aren't serving life sentences for the murder of [Name removed]!

You always use that as an excuse when points are put to you! but you can post as many general links to 100s of situations, personality issues murders and many other topics  that you like but they are all general too. That is always ok isnt it? 

[justsaying]

Not actually true though is it seeing as the holiday was cancelled and Luke had no means to plan/see her whatsoever

If ifs and ands were pots and pans 

[jixy]

What was the first reaction that was noted when he first discovered Jodi? doesnt match that description but easy to lose that along the way like most of the evidence!

[jixy]

As a further note how could Dobbie "evaluate" Luke's psychology? LIKE YOU he is NOT a psychologist!

No and he wasnt very good at his job was he?

[jixy]

Perhaps you should read up on the criminal spin and focus on Luke Mitchell's behaviour, emotions and cognition!

 

[Nicholas]

What size were the bottles seized by police and how long do you think it took LM to fill?

They weren't linked to trauma either were they

[jixy]

Luke Mitchell's behaviour, emotions and cognition are relevant

Like all the emotion he displayed during his interrogation where they tried to crack him. Over and over he said he didnt kill Jodi over and over the Police lied and said he wasnt under suspicion of  murder so they could abuse him further.

What about their behaviour and emotions. Trained Police Officers that couldnt even keep hold of their temper! what do you make of them?

[jixy]

Why didn't Shane Mitchell corroborate his brothers alibi during trial and why does it appear he's never supported his brothers claims publicly in all these years?

Are you aware of the treatment Shane suffered at the hands of the Police?

[justsaying]

They weren't linked to trauma either were they

They probably would have been had he been evaluated for PTSD - it is a classic sign of trauma, but you just like to look at the most sinister reasons 

[jixy]

What size were the bottles seized by police and how long do you think it took LM to fill?

why are you obsessed with them?