Nope, don't agree with that, none of the girls abducted & later found were fine & looked after, neither were they dead. They were snatched & held captives against their will, though these girls were older than Madeleine, that's sadly a possibility that cannot be discarded.
I agree, Mrs B
Unhappily John, what you are saying is also true in that Madeleine will have an awful time trying to readjust. Her family too.
Seems to me that she is bound to be psychologically damaged.
One thing is quite certain, and that is that she cannot be left with people who abduct.
I think that she will have memories of her daddy and possibly her mummy and the twins. Gerry was very involved with all his kids. A noisy boistrous terrific dad.
Kate was a kind and loving mother to Madeleine ... and still is to the twins.
I think she will remember bits, so long as she hasn't been deliberately mind programmed/ treated in any way to forget her past. Pray God she hasn't.