The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[misty]

What was what ????

The crying baby in the video is very much good representation of how a distressed child would cry.

‘She also refers to the day of the 1st May 2007, when she was at home alone, at approximately 22.30 she heard a child cry, and that due the tone of the crying seemed to be a young child and not a baby of two years of age or younger. Apart from the crying that continued for approximately one hour and fifteen minutes, and which got louder and more expressive, the child shouted ?Daddy, Daddy?, ’

Poor child.

If you have any evidence to refute Mrs Fenn’s statement then perhaps you could post it here because so far the only thing I can see is emotive language posted to divert attention from the real issue.

IMO when Robert Murat was made an arguido, less than 2 weeks after Madeleine disappeared, Mrs Fenn's testimony at that crucial time stating Madeleine was unsettled & upset for over an hour on the Tuesday night may have helped in his defence. I wonder why she apparently chose not to mention the episode until several weeks later?

[slartibartfast]

Please return to the topic.

[G-Unit]

IMO when Robert Murat was made an arguido, less than 2 weeks after Madeleine disappeared, Mrs Fenn's testimony at that crucial time stating Madeleine was unsettled & upset for over an hour on the Tuesday night may have helped in his defence. I wonder why she apparently chose not to mention the episode until several weeks later?

I can see no connection between Madeleine crying on 1st and Robert Murat being suspected of being involved in something on 3rd.

[faithlilly]

I can see no connection between Madeleine crying on 1st and Robert Murat being suspected of being involved in something on 3rd.

I think it’s a bit like the supporters mantra that the Smiths came forward to give Murat an alibi.

It’s strange that they think that Mrs Fenn and most of the Smith family, who only knew Murat in passing, would lie for him yet find ridiculous the contention that the tapas group would lie to save their friends from prosecution.

[Venturi Swirl]

I think it’s a bit like the supporters mantra that the Smiths came forward to give Murat an alibi.

It’s strange that they think that Mrs Fenn and most of the Smith family, who only knew Murat in passing, would lie for him yet find ridiculous the contention that the tapas group would lie to save their friends from prosecution.

and yet you seem to find one of the above scenarios perfectly plausible!

[misty]

I think it’s a bit like the supporters mantra that the Smiths came forward to give Murat an alibi.

It’s strange that they think that Mrs Fenn and most of the Smith family, who only knew Murat in passing, would lie for him yet find ridiculous the contention that the tapas group would lie to save their friends from prosecution.

You have totally missed the point. A local man, UK ex-pat, son of a long-established Luz resident, was being accused of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance. Would it not have been helpful to both him & the investigating officers to have been told of this crying incident there & then? The investigation could have potentially looked at other avenues e.g. the Tapas group, when memories were fresh, rather than dither along until options were running out?

[Brietta]

You have totally missed the point. A local man, UK ex-pat, son of a long-established Luz resident, was being accused of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance. Would it not have been helpful to both him & the investigating officers to have been told of this crying incident there & then? The investigation could have potentially looked at other avenues e.g. the Tapas group, when memories were fresh, rather than dither along until options were running out?

I think the same goes for the Smith sighting ... if Tannerman was pivotal of putting the heat under him ... Smith man could have been enough to turn it down a bit had the PJ known about it.

[Robittybob1]

I think the same goes for the Smith sighting ... if Tannerman was pivotal of putting the heat under him ... Smith man could have been enough to turn it down a bit had the PJ known about it.

Tannerman - 9:15 according to Jane.  Robert Murat at 9:15 was at home with his mother wasn't he?  Was that alibi not good enough?
So if the timing of Tannerman had to change you can't have the same abductor going off in opposite directions. (if Tannerman and Smithman were one and the same.)

[sadie]

It is a bit unusual for a daughter to cry out for her "Daddy" isn't it?

Nah !

[G-Unit]

You have totally missed the point. A local man, UK ex-pat, son of a long-established Luz resident, was being accused of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance. Would it not have been helpful to both him & the investigating officers to have been told of this crying incident there & then? The investigation could have potentially looked at other avenues e.g. the Tapas group, when memories were fresh, rather than dither along until options were running out?

Mrs Fenn's evidence suggested that the checks weren't as frequent as the group reported. I think the PJ already suspected that quite early on.

[Brietta]

This thread is entitled:  The last video taken of Madeleine McCann

Please start the day off with posting On Topic.  Thank you

[faithlilly]

You have totally missed the point. A local man, UK ex-pat, son of a long-established Luz resident, was being accused of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance. Would it not have been helpful to both him & the investigating officers to have been told of this crying incident there & then? The investigation could have potentially looked at other avenues e.g. the Tapas group, when memories were fresh, rather than dither along until options were running out?

It may have been but unfortunately they weren’t. Does this make Mrs Fenn’s evidence any less credible ?

[Brietta]

I think the purpose of the release of the last video taken of Madeleine has been entirely lost to a section of individuals who saw it only as yet another opportunity to vent their spleen on her parents.

Has anyone given the slightest thought why Madeleine's parents would release such a precious memento of a few seconds of Madeleine's journey into the public domain?

Surely a video is even better than photographs for identification purposes.  Releasing the video on the 29th May 2007 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg473912#msg473912 was in my opinion a desperate attempt to give the public as good a representation of Madeleine as possible in the hope that someone seeing her might recognise her.

Yet another useful tool released to benefit Madeleine was corrupted to be used against her in my opinion.

[Miss Taken Identity]

You have totally missed the point. A local man, UK ex-pat, son of a long-established Luz resident, was being accused of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance. Would it not have been helpful to both him & the investigating officers to have been told of this crying incident there & then? The investigation could have potentially looked at other avenues e.g. the Tapas group, when memories were fresh, rather than dither along until options were running out?

So why didn't the McCanns report this incident at once, I wonder...

[Miss Taken Identity]

I think the purpose of the release of the last video taken of Madeleine has been entirely lost to a section of individuals who saw it only as yet another opportunity to vent their spleen on her parents.

Has anyone given the slightest thought why Madeleine's parents would release such a precious memento of a few seconds of Madeleine's journey into the public domain?

Surely a video is even better than photographs for identification purposes.  Releasing the video on the 29th May 2007 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg473912#msg473912 was in my opinion a desperate attempt to give the public as good a representation of Madeleine as possible in the hope that someone seeing her might recognise her.

Yet another useful tool released to benefit Madeleine was corrupted to be used against her in my opinion.

What an accusation in red bold font. A pile of poo ofcourse.

Was it the McCanns who released that particular video and then you say it was dubbed?  wow seriously.