The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[Brietta]

Not sure why you think the booms prove the soundtrack is not authentic. Surely even you can appreciate that while individuals are boarding a plane and baggage being loaded there is multiple reasons why you would hear loud noises.

Why do you find it so difficult to believe that Gerry did actually swear ? Surely that’s a more logical explanation than the added soundtrack conspiracy you are trying to push ? It does however explain your behaviour. If you can’t stomach the idea that Gerry would swear, hearing that he may have been involved in his daughter’s disappearance must bring you to apoplexy.

Give me one single reason why any video footage posted on the internet should be trusted unconditionally?

[jassi]

Give me one single reason why any video footage posted on the internet should be trusted unconditionally?

Why should video footage be less trusted than anything else on the internet?

[Sunny]

Give me one single reason why any video footage posted on the internet should be trusted unconditionally?

I suppose the video is a bit like Madeleine's "last photo" then. Some doubt it's authenticity others swear by it. All IMO.

[faithlilly]

Give me one single reason why any video footage posted on the internet should be trusted unconditionally?

Because we have been given no reason to doubt it ?

[Sunny]

That is a lot like the "last photo" then.

[Brietta]

Why should video footage be less trusted than anything else on the internet?

Quite.

[Brietta]

Because we have been given no reason to doubt it ?

There is something rather sweet about trusting internet posts that you cannot possibly know the provenance of ... I actually did not suppose such naivety still existed.

[slartibartfast]

There is something rather sweet about trusting internet posts that you cannot possibly know the provenance of ... I actually did not suppose such naivety still existed.

Like the last picture?

[faithlilly]

There is something rather sweet about trusting internet posts that you cannot possibly know the provenance of ... I actually did not suppose such naivety still existed.

Do you really think that that kind of naivety exists in any of this after this case ?

We know the provenance of this video because it has been covered extensively in the press and we know there was a soundtrack for the same reason. Further we know most of the content of the video because it was included in press articles about it. That you choose to believe that there is some ridiculous conspiracy to convince the public that Gerry said a bad word ( really ? ) is a matter for you alone.

[G-Unit]

There is something rather sweet about trusting internet posts that you cannot possibly know the provenance of ... I actually did not suppose such naivety still existed.

Some trust politicians, the police, the media, even people they don't know. Each to his pwn I say.

[Mr Gray]

Some trust politicians, the police, the media, even people they don't know. Each to his pwn I say.

we all have to trust some one...the important thing is knowing who to trust

[Brietta]

Do you really think that that kind of naivety exists in any of this after this case ?

We know the provenance of this video because it has been covered extensively in the press and we know there was a soundtrack for the same reason. Further we know most of the content of the video because it was included in press articles about it. That you choose to believe that there is some ridiculous conspiracy to convince the public that Gerry said a bad word ( really ? ) is a matter for you alone.

There is a cite at the beginning of this thread indicting that the owners of the footage released it minus audio ... thus the audio track was added by someone ... I have no idea who that may have been and I am willing to bet that neither do you.

[John]

Members are reminded that cites must be provided in accordance with the forum rules. On several occasions recently cites have been requested but never provided. Asking for a cite is not goading but compliance.

From this moment onward, posts making significant claims which are not backed up by a cite will be removed.

Moderators and Editors take note!

[faithlilly]

There is a cite at the beginning of this thread indicting that the owners of the footage released it minus audio ... thus the audio track was added by someone ... I have no idea who that may have been and I am willing to bet that neither do you.

Already been posted but obviously you missed it.

https://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/girl-slips-and-grazes-her-shin-on-steps-to-aircraft-in-video-footage-released-by-desperate-parents-1-2456983

From the article.

‘Mr McCann is looking serious, which prompts his friend to joke: “Cheer up Gerry, we are on holiday.” Laughter is heard throughout the rest of the clip.’

[faithlilly]

‘‘Mr McCann is looking serious, which prompts his friend to joke: “Cheer up Gerry, we are on holiday.” Laughter is heard throughout the rest of the clip.’

Do you still believe the video was doctored at a later date Brietta because this article is dated 28th of May 2007, the same date as similar articles from the BBC etc ?