The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[G-Unit]

‘‘Mr McCann is looking serious, which prompts his friend to joke: “Cheer up Gerry, we are on holiday.” Laughter is heard throughout the rest of the clip.’

Do you still believe the video was doctored at a later date Brietta because this article is dated 28th of May 2007, the same date as similar articles from the BBC etc ?

Actually the Yorkshire Post seems to have scooped the story. The other reports seem to be dated 29th May.

[faithlilly]

Actually the Yorkshire Post seems to have scooped the story. The other reports seem to be dated 29th May.

Thank you for the clarification G.

[Brietta]

Already been posted but obviously you missed it.

https://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/girl-slips-and-grazes-her-shin-on-steps-to-aircraft-in-video-footage-released-by-desperate-parents-1-2456983

From the article.

‘Mr McCann is looking serious, which prompts his friend to joke: “Cheer up Gerry, we are on holiday.” Laughter is heard throughout the rest of the clip.’

No ... I did not miss it then or now ... despite the fact there is no mention of profanity in the audio track of the video which was released by its owners without one.

[Sunny]

No ... I did not miss it then or now ... despite the fact there is no mention of profanity in the audio track of the video which was released by its owners without one.

Did you expect the newspaper to quote Gerry saying "fxx off" Brietta? I think they covered it nicely and it shows that there was originally a soundtract which fits in with the one currently online.

[faithlilly]

No ... I did not miss it then or now ... despite the fact there is no mention of profanity in the audio track of the video which was released by its owners without one.

Now you are moving the goalposts. You said the soundtrack was added. It obviously wasn’t. Do you now accept that ?

[Brietta]

Did you expect the newspaper to quote Gerry saying "fxx off" Brietta? I think they covered it nicely and it shows that there was originally a soundtract which fits in with the one currently online.

In your opinion perhaps ... most certainly not in mine.

[faithlilly]

In your opinion perhaps ... most certainly not in mine.

Now you’re just making yourself look silly Brietta. The article posted tells you that there was a soundtrack attached to the video. Why do you still think the soundtrack was added later ?

[Brietta]

Now you’re just making yourself look silly Brietta. The article posted tells you that there was a soundtrack attached to the video. Why do you still think the soundtrack was added later ?

Please remember your manners when you post and remember also to differentiate between what is your opinion and what is fact.

[faithlilly]

Please remember your manners when you post and remember also to differentiate between what is your opinion and what is fact.

And please remember that we are all adults here and don’t need to be lectured in such a condescending way.

As to the video I am not stating my opinion but a fact, a fact for which I have already supplied a cite twice. You said when originally released the video had no soundtrack. I have supplied a contemporary newspaper article that proves that there was indeed a soundtrack and further supplies extracts from that soundtrack. Further the extracts  detailed in the newspaper article exactly mirror the soundtrack we see on YouTube.

[Brietta]

And please remember that we are all adults here and don’t need to be lectured in such a condescending way.

As to the video I am not stating my opinion but a fact, a fact for which I have already supplied a cite twice. You said when originally released the video had no soundtrack. I have supplied a contemporary newspaper article that proves that there was indeed a soundtrack and further supplies extracts from that soundtrack. Further the extracts  detailed in the newspaper article exactly mirror thes soundtrack we see on YouTube.

There are links to two videos on the forum.

One link is to the video released by Madeleine's parents without a soundtrack. 

The other was released by who knows and has a sound track.  But sound or the lack of it is not the only difference.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg467275#msg467275

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg473455#msg473455

Did you spot the difference?

[faithlilly]

There are links to two videos on the forum.

One link is to the video released by Madeleine's parents without a soundtrack. 

The other was released by who knows and has a sound track.  But sound or the lack of it is not the only difference.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg467275#msg467275

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg473455#msg473455

Did you spot the difference?

The newspaper article was published on the 28th of May and describes a soundtrack which mirrors the soundtrack we see in the YouTube video. I believe this report was one of the earliest.

Anything else is deflection.

[Brietta]

The newspaper article was published on the 28th of May and describes a soundtrack which mirrors the soundtrack we see in the YouTube video. I believe this report was one of the earliest.

Anything else is deflection.

The sequence of the edits in the official video released by Madeleine's parents differs from the YouTube video to which you refer.

If the sequence of the edit was reversed in the YouTube video ... don't you think the soundtrack was also subject to interference?

That the visual evidence does not reflect your opinion does not make it 'deflection' ... it makes it 'fact'.

[misty]

There are links to two videos on the forum.

One link is to the video released by Madeleine's parents without a soundtrack. 

The other was released by who knows and has a sound track.  But sound or the lack of it is not the only difference.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg467275#msg467275

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9636.msg473455#msg473455

Did you spot the difference?

The original silent video has Madeleine highlighted, which isn't the case in the video complete with audio.
UK media outlets must have been supplied with videos + audio to know what Gerry said as Madeleine tripped on the steps. I cannot find any other existing copy uploaded by UK media still online - can anyone else?
Presumably the PJ already had a copy of the video footage after confiscating the mobile phones on 4th May 2007..........surely they wouldn't have allowed such footage to inadvertently find its way out of that ever-open window?

[G-Unit]

The original silent video has Madeleine highlighted, which isn't the case in the video complete with audio.
UK media outlets must have been supplied with videos + audio to know what Gerry said as Madeleine tripped on the steps. I cannot find any other existing copy uploaded by UK media still online - can anyone else?
Presumably the PJ already had a copy of the video footage after confiscating the mobile phones on 4th May 2007..........surely they wouldn't have allowed such footage to inadvertently find its way out of that ever-open window?

What evidence do you have that the PJ confiscated anyone's mobile phone on 4th May 2007?

[faithlilly]

The sequence of the edits in the official video released by Madeleine's parents differs from the YouTube video to which you refer.

If the sequence of the edit was reversed in the YouTube video ... don't you think the soundtrack was also subject to interference?

That the visual evidence does not reflect your opinion does not make it 'deflection' ... it makes it 'fact'.

The Yorkshire Post, one of the first newspapers to print the video story, specifically claims that there was a soundtrack with the video. That soundtrack mirrors the soundtrack on the video which now can be seen on YouTube. Between the release of the video and the YP’s article there was no time to ‘interfere’ with anything.

You stated there was no soundtrack on the original video. I have proved beyond doubt that there was. That the sequence of sections of that video may have been changed in subsequent postings  ( are you suggesting Reuters interfered with the video ? ) is absolutely nothing to do with the soundtrack which has remained consistent throughout.