Should the Germans Have Dropped Their Investigation By Now?

[Mr Gray]

I'm thinking it is only "evidence" when you say what it points to.

For example, if you say "concrete evidence" against CB,  it is evidence that CB committed some crime or other.
Do you agree that we need to define what the evidence points to?

IMO it is wrong to say you have concrete evidence unless you say what the evidence points to.

Wolters had said concrete evidence that CB murdered Maddie

[Robittybob1]

Wolters had said concrete evidence that CB murdered Maddie

So it is not evidence he abducted her, or evidence he was in the apartment.  Not even just evidence she is dead, but evidence he killed her?  What sort of evidence is that?

[barrier]

So it is not evidence he abducted her, or evidence he was in the apartment.  Not even just evidence she is dead, but evidence he killed her?  What sort of evidence is that?

Head line grab, his evidence may only be in the form of some one saying his suspect killed her.

[Mr Gray]

So it is not evidence he abducted her, or evidence he was in the apartment.  Not even just evidence she is dead, but evidence he killed her?  What sort of evidence is that?

Its quite simple...evidence she is dead and Cb murdered her. Thats what HCW has said. Have you not watched the 60 mins documentary

[Mr Gray]

Head line grab, his evidence may only be in the form of some one saying his suspect killed her.

thats in the public domain...so very unlikely and certainly not concrete

[jassi]

So it is not evidence he abducted her, or evidence he was in the apartment.  Not even just evidence she is dead, but evidence he killed her?  What sort of evidence is that?

We may never know

[Robittybob1]

Head line grab, his evidence may only be in the form of some one saying his suspect killed her.

But was that considered "concrete"? 

A confession was considered concrete in that list of uses of the words "concrete evidence".

A confession taken under caution may be considered concrete evidence, but is that the same as for a statement from a "friend" of CB who says CB confessed to them?  Is that concrete or quicksand?

[barrier]

But was that considered "concrete"? 

A confession was considered concrete in that list of uses of the words "concrete evidence".

A confession taken under caution may be considered concrete evidence, but is that the same as for a statement from a "friend" of CB who says CB confessed to them?  Is that concrete or quicksand?

Its concrete that some one said so, not proof of the actual deed.

[Mr Gray]

But was that considered "concrete"? 

A confession was considered concrete in that list of uses of the words "concrete evidence".

A confession taken under caution may be considered concrete evidence, but is that the same as for a statement from a "friend" of CB who says CB confessed to them?  Is that concrete or quicksand?

Wolters said he is sure Maddie is dead and is sure CB killed her....beleive what you wish

[Eleanor]

We may never know

I think you may be right.

[barrier]

Wolters said he is sure Maddie is dead and is sure CB killed her....beleive what you wish

The way he flipflopped back in June its best to be circumspect when it comes to his words.

[Mr Gray]

I think you may be right.

I think we will. At some stage he will ahve to explain to the parents.

[Eleanor]

I think we will. At some stage he will ahve to explain to the parents.

But will they tell the public at large?

[jassi]

If Brueckner is arrested/questioned, then this evidence will come out.

However if this does not happen then the Germans will b reluctant for this evidence to become common knowledge just in case they can make use of it later.

IMO there is no reason why the parents should be party to this information if Brueckner is not questioned and prosecuted

[Mr Gray]

If Brueckner is arrested/questioned, then this evidence will come out.

However if this does not happen then the Germans will b reluctant for this evidence to become common knowledge just in case they can make use of it later.

IMO there is no reason why the parents should be party to this information if Brueckner is not questioned and prosecuted

That could well be the case