Should the Germans Have Dropped Their Investigation By Now?

[G-Unit]

they can think what they like but the fact they misunderstood the evidence makes their conclusions useles. even the proven facts in the police files are wrong

Let us not forget that Operation Grange were instructed to pursue a certain line of inquiry without any evidence being offered to justify that decision. Unless Rowley's revelation that four year olds don't decide to go off and start a new life can be classed as evidence, of course.

[Angelo222]

There's no wishful thinking..as Simon Foy has said... The Germans must have something significant based on what they have said

They thought that by issuing statements effectively putting Brueckner in the frame that someone would come forward to provide the little thing called evidence. Obviously they were wrong and are now effectively pissing up against a very high wall.

The fact that nobody came forward to collect their twenty pieces of silver says it all imo.

[Mr Gray]

Let us not forget that Operation Grange were instructed to pursue a certain line of inquiry without any evidence being offered to justify that decision. Unless Rowley's revelation that four year olds don't decide to go off and start a new life can be classed as evidence, of course.

I think there was a lot more to it than  that but you pick up on one phrase....I understand the point he was making....you could call it the Myasia Gibbs point...and yes it is evidence

[Angelo222]

Let us not forget that Operation Grange were instructed to pursue a certain line of inquiry without any evidence being offered to justify that decision. Unless Rowley's revelation that four year olds don't decide to go off and start a new life can be classed as evidence, of course.

      SY really cocked this one up imo.  Redwood got closest to solving it imo but he didn't have the resources to conduct a proper search.

[Mr Gray]

They thought that by issuing statements effectively putting Brueckner in the frame that someone would come forward to provide the little thing called evidence. Obviously they were wrong and are now effectively pissing up against a very high wall.

The fact that nobody came forward to collect their twenty pieces of silver says it all imo.

oh dear angelo...pride before  a fall springs to mind. I go with Simon Foy...ex scotland yard who says they have something significant

[kizzy]

No I'm right...what were all those doggie posts about.. Lol

what were all those doggie posts about


Well obviously  dogs

[Angelo222]

oh dear angelo...pride before  a fall springs to mind. I go with Simon Foy...ex scotland yard who says they have something significant

Foy's genius moment or not, was when he claimed the parents were not involved on the basis that they weren't at the apartment when the child disappeared. Problem about this is that nobody outside the parents and another doctor saw Maddie after 5.30pm so nobody knows when she actually disappeared. There is a window of over 4½ hours in which anything could have happened.

[Mr Gray]

Foy's genius moment or not, was when he claimed the parents were not involved on the basis that they weren't at the apartment when the child disappeared. Problem about this is that nobody outside the parents and another doctor saw Maddie after 5.30pm so nobody knows when she actually disappeared. There is a window of over 4½ hours in which anything could have happened.

iIt looks like the Germans now have that evidence

[Mr Gray]

what were all those doggie posts about


Well obviously  dogs

but not about evidence

[Eleanor]

Let us not forget that Operation Grange were instructed to pursue a certain line of inquiry without any evidence being offered to justify that decision. Unless Rowley's revelation that four year olds don't decide to go off and start a new life can be classed as evidence, of course.

Your opinion of Operation Grange has never been proved and is twisted to say the least.

[faithlilly]

Your opinion of Operation Grange has never been proved and is twisted to say the least.

I think OG has been stymied by unrealistic boundaries.

[kizzy]

but not about evidence

Well seems like Wolt hasn't got any evidence- but it doesn't stop you thinking he is right.

Or is it you that is taken in by what he keeps on repeating for the last nearon eight months?

[Angelo222]

iIt looks like the Germans now have that evidence

Same old, same old. If you can't fit up one suspect then move on to another. They'll spend months on Ney now that Brueckner has proven elusive.

[Mr Gray]

Same old, same old. If you can't fit up one suspect then move on to another. They'll spend months on Ney now that Brueckner has proven elusive.

So according to you the investigation in to  CB is over...
Let's see if you are right

[Venturi Swirl]

Foy's genius moment or not, was when he claimed the parents were not involved on the basis that they weren't at the apartment when the child disappeared. Problem about this is that nobody outside the parents and another doctor saw Maddie after 5.30pm so nobody knows when she actually disappeared. There is a window of over 4½ hours in which anything could have happened.

Anything?