Should the Germans Have Dropped Their Investigation By Now?

[The General]

I think that was one of those hindsight moments where information is later  added to support the narrative.

If you thought there was someone in your apartment, would you not check at the time. ?

Maybe he was too scared to check, so he left and went back to finish his pint?

[Venturi Swirl]

Absolutely but wasn’t it being suggested that Gerry knew at the Times?

Could we have the cite please?

[sadie]

Who felt that there was someone around?

Gerry had a feeling.   It is in the statements somewhere if you are interested.  Surely you have read it?

[G-Unit]

Gerry had a feeling.   It is in the statements somewhere if you are interested.  Surely you have read it?

I think you are mistaken Sadie. Unless, of course, you have a cite.

[faithlilly]

Could we have the cite please?

If you look back a few posts that appeared to be what Sadie posted. Perhaps she could clarify?

[Robittybob1]

Gerry had a feeling.   It is in the statements somewhere if you are interested.  Surely you have read it?

It was on the video that the Tapas group did to show how things unfolded that night.  Gerry says words to that effect.   We may be misinterpreting what he said, but I thought he was overemphasizing the drama of the situation.

[Mr Gray]

It was on the video that the Tapas group did to show how things unfolded that night.  Gerry says words to that effect.   We may be misinterpreting what he said, but I thought he was overemphasizing the drama of the situation.

perhaps you and sadie are misunderstanding what he said...so what did he say

[jassi]

It was on the video that the Tapas group did to show how things unfolded that night.  Gerry says words to that effect.   We may be misinterpreting what he said, but I thought he was overemphasizing the drama of the situation.

I think it wrong to treat anything in these documentaries as gospel,  they are more a dramatic interpretation of events.
IMO

[Robittybob1]

perhaps you and sadie are misunderstanding what he said...so what did he say

It was the same video where he turns the light on when he enters Madeleine's room.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7981.0

"This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Mentorn Media Limited."  I wonder if there was another version.

[Mr Gray]

It was the same video where he turns the light on when he enters Madeleine's room.

Sadie seems to be saying.. And you agreeing with her... That when Herry entered the apartment he said he felt someone was in there.. I'm pretty sure that isn't true

[Robittybob1]

Sadie seems to be saying.. And you agreeing with her... That when Herry entered the apartment he said he felt someone was in there.. I'm pretty sure that isn't true

Unless we can find the video "Madeleine was here" we won't be able to check it at this late stage.

It seems to be here https://youtu.be/TiYmcU8QxYo  That is part 1 we'd need to all parts of it.

Part 2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wz0ZBJmy7B0

[I might still have the reference wrong.]

[Mr Gray]

Unless we can find the video "Madelene was here" we won't be able to check it at this late stage.

It seems to be here https://youtu.be/TiYmcU8QxYo  That is part 1 we'd need to all parts of it.

Thats fine so Sadies post is opinion not fact

AFAIK he said at a later date... Perhaps the abductor was in the apt... Not that he had a feeling at the time there was someone else there... That sounds absurd to mr

[Robittybob1]

Thats fine so Sadies post is opinion not fact

AFAIK he said at a later date... Perhaps the abductor was in the apt... Not that he had a feeling at the time there was someone else there... That sounds absurd to mr

It is a problem when our perceptions are based on videos that get taken off YouTube at a later stage.

[Mr Gray]

It is a problem when our perceptions are based on videos that get taken off YouTube at a later stage.

them its not  a fact...simple...and should not be claimed as a fact

[Robittybob1]

them its not  a fact...simple...and should not be claimed as a fact

Is that logical.   It was a fact when the video existed.  Is into longer a fact since the video is taken down?    To me it seems just to put the argument into the impossible to solve category at this stage. 

You need to consult a lawyer about the legality of it.