Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

no he didn't...you are still being dishonest

yup, exactly what he said, your apoplexy is puzzling

[mercury]

yet SY say the McCanns are not suspects and are still spending millions investigating in portugal

nope SY said Mccanns were not suspects in a certain context, same with PJ, stop lyng

 

[Benice]

suggestive means just that, it suggests, points to, indicates  it doesnt mean "i have no clue and it could be bad breath or sausages"

cadaver scent means = from a dead body

Not necessarily from a dead body mercury, -  hair, teeth and fingernails can be parted from their live owners at times and would decompose.   Also an alert could be to a scent which had been innocently transferred there from another source.    I could also be to a scent emanating from underground.

Without corroborating evidence no-one can say which scenario it is.

Quote from THE SUN  - (Yes I know  - but it's in quotation marks - so a direct quote)

Martin Grime:-

: "Blood could be invisible to the naked eye, but Keela will detect it. It doesn't matter if it's hundreds of years old.  "Eddie smells for the scent of a decomposing human body. He can detect any part of a human body that is decomposing - hair, bones, flesh, anything. "The smell of a decomposing body is very difficult to get rid of. It can easily be transferred to clothing and on to a person."

Unquote

[pathfinder73]

yet SY say the McCanns are not suspects and are still spending millions investigating in portugal

They are not suspects and are spending millions to close this case for good. The circus can wait.

[Mr Gray]

They are not suspects and are spending millions to close this case for good. The circus can wait.

just one more question...howdya know that

[mercury]

Not necessarily from a dead body mercury, -  hair, teeth and fingernails can be parted from their live owners at times and would decompose.   Also an alert could be to a scent which had been innocently transferred there from another source.    I could also be to a scent emanating from underground.

Without corroborating evidence no-one can say which scenario it is.

Quote from THE SUN  - (Yes I know  - but it's in quotation marks - so a direct quote)

Martin Grime:-

: "Blood could be invisible to the naked eye, but Keela will detect it. It doesn't matter if it's hundreds of years old.  "Eddie smells for the scent of a decomposing human body. He can detect any part of a human body that is decomposing - hair, bones, flesh, anything. "The smell of a decomposing body is very difficult to get rid of. It can easily be transferred to clothing and on to a person."

Unquote

remember my orignal question benice, why indications to ONLY 5a living or dead derived....no one cN answer this

[Benice]

remember my orignal question benice, why indications to ONLY 5a living or dead derived....no one cN answer this

Well IMO mercury it's because far more time was spent on everything McCann related than on anything else.   If the same time had been spent on the non-McCann related cars and apartments then it's my firm belief that alerts would also have occurred in those places.

In view of Martin Grime's claim  (which I believe) that his dogs could alert to the tiniest of scents, even decades of years old  -which cannot be removed by cleaning  - then I simply can't accept that not one speck of blood was ever spilt in any part of those other apartments or cars over such a long period of time.    Sorry but that's just not credible IMO.

[pathfinder73]

Well IMO mercury it's because far more time was spent on everything McCann related than on anything else.   If the same time had been spent on the non-McCann related cars and apartments then it's my firm belief that alerts would also have occurred in those places.

In view of Martin Grime's claim  (which I believe) that his dogs could alert to the tiniest of scents, even decades of years old  -which cannot be removed by cleaning  - then I simply can't accept that not one speck of blood was ever spilt in any part of those other apartments or cars over such a long period of time.    Sorry but that's just not credible IMO.

Keela is not used unless Eddie alerts. Eddie only alerted in 5A. Eddie goes in first to detect death. If he detects it Keela is brought in to find any trace of blood i.e. of the missing person. These dogs are used to find evidence in murder cases. SY homicide team are working on this case.

[Benice]

Keela is not used unless Eddie alerts. Eddie only alerted in 5A. Eddie goes in first to detect death. If he detects it Keela is brought in to find any trace of blood i.e. of the missing person. These dogs are used to find evidence in murder cases. SY homicide team are working on this case.

Yes I know what Eddie and Keela do (or did)  but what has any of that got to do with my post?

[pathfinder73]

Yes I know what Eddie and Keela do (or did)  but what has any of that got to do with my post?

Your post is meaningless. Did they find any teeth in the wardrobe or on the clothes?

[Benice]

Your post is meaningless. Did they find any teeth in the wardrobe or on the clothes?

Even if the decomposing material has gone - the residual scent remains.    Eddie detected nothing except scent - which could be there for a number of reasons, and not all associated with the presence of a dead body. 

[Brietta]

Your post is meaningless. Did they find any teeth in the wardrobe or on the clothes?

Actually it was Eddie's alerts which were and are meaningless.

[pathfinder73]

Actually it was Eddie's alerts which were and are meaningless.

Eddie's alerts are never meaningless as past cases prove.

[sadie]

Eddie's alerts are never meaningless as past cases prove.

Eddies alerts are meaningless without any corroborating evidence.  There was no corroborating evidence.


And you KNOW IT.



Why do you keep pushing untruths Pfinder.

[G-Unit]

Eddies alerts are meaningless without any corroborating evidence.  There was no corroborating evidence.


And you KNOW IT.



Why do you keep pushing untruths Pfinder.

Some think Eddie was right, others think he was wrong. On balance he was very good at what he did. Keela proved him right twice. His alerts are definitely not meaningless in my opinion.