Amaral and the dogs

[pathfinder73]

Much along the lines of the interesting tit bit he fished out of a kitchen waste bin.

Eddie barks when he alerts.

[mercury]

Much along the lines of the interesting tit bit he fished out of a kitchen waste bin.

Irrelevant as confirmed by Mr Grime, the "professional" rather than the "armchair" layman, or woman

[ferryman]

Irrelevant as confirmed by Mr Grime, the "professional" rather than the "armchair" layman, or woman

I would argue that it's a reasonably pertinent indicator of what reliance can be placed on Mr Grime's answers to questions ...

[ferryman]

Eddie barks when he alerts.

Or when he's miffed because his toy has been taken away from him ....

[mercury]

I would argue that it's a reasonably pertinent indicator of what reliance can be placed on Mr Grime's answers to questions ...

No, the only pertinent indicator here of anything is your libellous posts...its almost as if you might have an aneurism if the dog did alert to a dead body, true?

Difference between me and you is that Im open minded, and say I might be wrong,you on the other hand wont have any talk of it, which, is strange, unless youre one of the Mccanns, or the abductor, both of  which Im sure is untrue, so how you can be so categoric is beynd me

[ferryman]

No, the only pertinent indicator here of anything is your libellous posts...its almost as if you might have an aneurism if the dog did alert to a dead body, true?

Difference between me and you is that Im open minded, and say I might be wrong,you on the other hand wont have any talk of it, which, is strange, unless youre one of the Mccanns, or the abductor, both of  which Im sure is untrue, so how you can be so categoric is beynd me

Grime did say that, at his request, the toy was retained by the judicial police for future forensic examination.

That wasn't true.

The toy was returned to the McCanns.

[mercury]

Grime did say that, at his request, the toy was retained by the judicial police for future forensic examination.

That wasn't true.

The toy was returned to the McCanns.

Yes, we know, you have bleated long enough about it, fact remains you didnt answer my original question, thng is you cant ignore questions then demand answers for your own

[ferryman]

I (first!) learnt of the existence of the McCann family at some point after May 3rd 2007.

[pegasus]

Grime did say that, at his request, the toy was retained by the judicial police for future forensic examination.

That wasn't true.

The toy was returned to the McCanns.

"Apartment 5H. We searched this apartment and the dog hasn’t shown any interest in this particular apartment, apart from around the table, where there was a tennis ball which is how we reward the dog for finding things, as soon as we removed the tennis ball the interest was gone. And so it was a negative search."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

[mercury]

I (first!) learnt of the existence of the McCann family at some point after May 3rd 2007.

never thought otherwise dear

[pathfinder73]

Or when he's miffed because his toy has been taken away from him ....

No he was trained not to bark except for when he alerts. He doesn't bark when he's playing with tennis balls or toys.

[mercury]

No he was trained not to bark except for when he alerts. He doesn't bark when he's playing with tennis balls or toys.

it is true though PF that he didnt bark when he first encountered that toy....why not?
I watched the video and did hear a reaction but not a loud bark as when he alerted outside that sideboard

[Eleanor]

Posts containing insults will be deleted.

[mercury]

Posts containing insults will be deleted.

not seen any here much  Eleanor, but must go save my posts just in case anythng pertinent is removed

[ferryman]

No he was trained not to bark except for when he alerts. He doesn't bark when he's playing with tennis balls or toys.

So why could he detect a scent when the toy was in the cupboard, but not when it was in front of his nose and he could sniff it, pick it up and play with it.

And why are not police dogs attending a crime scene trained never to pick up anything at all?