Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

never implied there were...perhaps you have inferred incorrectly

yup, you surely did in post 1303... suggested the possibility...your theoretical possibility was removed by the police who stated the fact there were none

[mercury]

amaral got the basic facts totally wrong...which is inexcusable as the SIO

no evidence he did so

[G-Unit]

No way, Davel is an intelligent super iq know it all poster with the best arguments around, we are all so stupid compared etc

Stop being so silly, its FAR more likely that Mr Amaral visited the local morgue and swept his hanky over the nearest corpse then popped along to flat 5a pretending to have a sniffle whilst surreptitiously wiping said hanky over furniture etc

Bloody Laurel and Hardy werent as funny!!

It's on a par with the 'source' who suggested that Kate Mccann and cuddle cat played with half a dozen corpses just before she went on holiday.

[Mr Gray]

of course he is...according to YOU then again he might not be, no need to get so het up really as its none of your business either way

you are a newcomer with poor knowledge of the facts...you were not aware that Tavares has now a conviction for torture...perhaps a little humility would be in order towards those with far more knowledge

[mercury]

It's on a par with the 'source' who suggested that Kate Mccann and cuddle cat played with half a dozen corpses just before she went on holiday.

OMG forgot all about that!
 

[Mr Gray]

no evidence he did so

there is absolute proof...even Stephen accepts...that he did

[Mr Gray]

yup, you surely did in post 1303... suggested the possibility...your theoretical possibility was removed by the police who stated the fact there were none

no I didn't...you are wrong yet  again.....

[mercury]

no I didn't...you are wrong yet  again.....

no, youre wrong, this is a copy of your post 1303 where you DID suggest exactly that in the last sentence!


Not at all , you are mistaken
There are several scenarios
Eddie could be wrong
Grime could be wrong
The alerts may have been due to contamination
There may have been a cadaver in the apartment previously

[sadie]

my post directly raised the possibility of planted evidence...this has to be considered a possibility

I have wondered that too.

Several things, which I have covered before, have made me wonder.

[pegasus]

amaral got the basic facts totally wrong...which is inexcusable as the SIO

Partly wrong, not totally wrong.

[Brietta]

Partly wrong, not totally wrong.

I think he managed to work out that Madeleine was missing ... can you think of anything else he got right?

[ferryman]

I think he managed to work out that Madeleine was missing ... can you think of anything else he got right?

David Payne saw Madeleine, alive and well, at around 1700 on May 3rd.

Amaral has never gone with before May 3rd.

[G-Unit]

David Payne saw Madeleine, alive and well, at around 1700 on May 3rd.

Amaral has never gone with before May 3rd.

According to all the statements David Payne was at the beach at 1700.

[Brietta]

David Payne saw Madeleine, alive and well, at around 1700 on May 3rd.

Amaral has never gone with before May 3rd.

Yeah ... I'll give him credit for that one ... but it didn't take rocket science to work it out.  Pity about the dogs though, he picked up what he wanted to hear from the handler and ignored anything that didn't fit in with his perception of how and who.

Classic error there in trying to make the evidence fit the theory ... it is good to see the professional work being done by the PJ and SY now who are doing what professionals do and following the evidence.

[stephen25000]

Yeah ... I'll give him credit for that one ... but it didn't take rocket science to work it out.  Pity about the dogs though, he picked up what he wanted to hear from the handler and ignored anything that didn't fit in with his perception of how and who.

Classic error there in trying to make the evidence fit the theory ... it is good to see the professional work being done by the PJ and SY now who are doing what professionals do and following the evidence.

and what these professionals found, after millions of Pounds and Euros spent ?

There is of course a simple one word answer.