Amaral and the dogs

[ferryman]

Occasionally, it is the antithesis of satisfying to be proved right ....

[stephen25000]

I don't need to read the Koran to reject Islaam...or all the other religious books...I don't need to read all of Icke's books to reject his message...etc , etc..

We have a comment from the PJ in the files that questions the alerts with good cause...fact

What expertise did the PJ representative have in the use of dogs ?

[ferryman]

What expertise did the PJ representative have in the use of dogs ?

[stephen25000]

Good answer ferryman.

NONE.

[Carew]

tries to narrow down the source of the scent........these are supposed to be the best dogs in the world...tossing cuddle cat up in the air and not alerting to it.....no

So much for the alleged "cuing and handler expectation" then,  due to such allegedly limited control and skill.

[ferryman]

What qualifications did Grime have to act as deputy crime-scene manager at HdLG?

[stephen25000]

What qualifications did Grime have to act as deputy crime-scene manager at HdLG?

More than a googler.

[Carew]

I don't recall Tito and Muzzy running around much ....

Ah...........in that case, the reply could be something like, " i.m.o.,  the dog was exhausted and alerted to get it over with."

(Or doesn`t that response "fit" on this occasion?)

[Alfred R Jones]

Carew, do you believe Eddie and Keela and their handler Martin Grime are above reproach?  Should they and the alerts not be questioned?  Is there absolutely nothing questionable about them at all in your view?

[Mr Gray]

What expertise did the PJ representative have in the use of dogs ?

That's why Grime was asked the question about cuddlecat ...remember..

It's only when you piece all the pieces of information together that you get the big picture. Grime was asked the question and he was unable to answer it...he had in fact been caught out...the alerts were basically useless

[ferryman]

More than a googler.

It's amazing what Google turns up:

The forensic review carried out by X of the NPIA
questioned the presence of Martin GRIME on site for such a long
time. X , was informed that Martin GRIME had been
acting as a Deputy Crime Scene Manager to Forensic Service
Manager X , at the request of DCO HARPER. The forensic
review noted Martin GRIME’s lack of formal training or qualifications
to perform the role of Deputy Forensic Service Manager and that to
utilise him in this role ‘cannot be recognised as good practice’. The
review also noted that ‘there was concern from some persons
interviewed that too much reliance had been placed on the dogs’.

(Operation Havern)

[Mr Gray]

More than a googler.

you will be surprised that intelligent professionals at the highest level use google  a lot.

[Carew]

Carew, do you believe Eddie and Keela and their handler Martin Grime are above reproach?  Should they and the alerts not be questioned?  Is there absolutely nothing questionable about them at all in your view?

The inconsistency revealed in certain comments about the dogs and their handler are there to be questioned or challenged .

As to your last couple of questions............apply them to your own and others` attitude to "questioning" or "doubting" the McCanns.

[stephen25000]

That's why Grime was asked the question about cuddlecat ...remember..

It's only when you piece all the pieces of information together that you get the big picture. Grime was asked the question and he was unable to answer it...he had in fact been caught out...the alerts were basically useless

The dogs were trained to detect the presence of a group of compounds.

[stephen25000]

The inconsistency revealed in certain comments about the dogs and their handler are there to be questioned or challenged .

As to your last couple of questions............apply them to your own and others` attitude to "questioning" or "doubting" the McCanns.

He doesn't get that Carew, not with his idols.

It's the personification of the mccann supporters one a dimensional logic.......