Deposition of: JOHN ROBERT LOWE BSc CBiol MlBiol RFP Age: Older than 18
Profession of Witness: Forensic Scientist
FSS-GF-679 Emissao 2, Pagina 8
An incomplete, low-level DNA profile that matched corresponding components in the profile of Gerald McCann was obtained from cellular material present on the card key - (286C/2007-CRL (12)).
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm
Just to clarify matters for you ...
there is no 'cherry picking' or obfuscation involved as I have made it plain that the reference quoted was made by Mr Grime in relation to what he had to say about Eddie's deployment in the garage
what a pity you assume I was patronising you as you have progressed to illustrate that you have clearly not understood what has been previously posted ... let me explain ...
Eddie woofed ... not at the boot where Keela subsequently alerted ... but at the driver's door of the Renault ... where Keela also alerted
according to Mr Grime Keela alerts only to blood ... therefore both these alerts were to blood
the Renault was moved to another floor of the garage
the key fob was secreted at a distance (fire service's bucket of sand)
Keela alerted to the key fob
Eddie alerted to the key fob
Eddie did not alert to the Renault from which the key fob had been removed
therefore Eddie did not alert to cadaver scent
Eddie alerted to what Keela did ... which we are told could only have been blood
I hope that helps you to a better understanding of my post.
You said nothng about Grime's comments pertaining to the garage, if you had done I wouldn't have responded with the words I did (ie that the only place he said in his opinion Eddie may have been alerting to cadaver scent OR blood)
As far as I understand it, Ferryman, Morse was fully accredited having been subject to regular independent testing ... also he was trained only on human scent.
Cite? morse was being trained in the UK in 2008, and as we are told, training on human bodies is illegal.
... and even if the hairs had been Madeleine's, without a root they would have signified nothing other than they were hers.
If death banding had been looked for, they would have signified more, but the PJs's request seems to have been ignored by the UK
The more benevolent minded, of members, remain to question or even rule out the alerts of the dog, which I might add…have no evidential value, without corroboration of evidential proof.
Whereas the more sceptic views, of other members remain in the believe that the alerts from the EVRD were evidence of cadaver scent. Who knows? They may be correct, but there is no evidence to support this.
IMO, The latter group would still be blaming the parents, even if the dogs hadn’t been brought in, whereas the former believe in innocent until proven otherwise.
A book is the cause of all of this and the fact that this case (unlike others) has all the PJ files online for all to study…. Only My opinion, of course.
Martin Grime states that in his professional opinion the alerts were suggestive of cadaver scent, it is not somethng plucked out of "sceptics unbenevolent" heads.
Which book? Surely not Amaral's? The news about the cadaver dog alerts was in the public domain and under discussion in the summer of 2007 a whole year before he published his book.
So indications is just another word for alerts....so the indications have NO evidential value either
No, an alert gives an indication of something, not the same, two different things. The indication, given by the EVRD dog's alerts, (and yes there are other
EVRDs in use by police in the UK according to the BBC at least) in Grime's own words, is to cadaver scent contaminant. (Or blood - the latter only in the case of the garage searches)
Unconfirmed indications have been described as legitimate cause for concern/suspicion, not much else on their own, but indications remain intelligence/circumstantial evidence. [/quote]
Why did Mark Harrison dismiss both inspections at villa and gym with these terse words?
Dismiss - treat as unworthy...where's your evidence he did any more than just state what the PJ exercises were
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4508.15I'm sure that poople as stupid as yourself will think I have made mistakes.....there you are a hat trick
Why do you feel the need to continuously break forum rules, being derogatory and calling people fools, stupid, uneducated, with poor understanding, and so on? Just wondering.
