Amaral and the dogs

[Eleanor]

You do know I presume organic remains millions of years old have been found ?

You appear to be talking about organic remains.  I am talking about Cadaver Scent where there are no remains.  If Cadaver Scent had an infinite life then we would all be stinking of it, including the other appartments occupied by the rest of The McCann Friends.

[Mr Gray]

You do not know that.

it depends on the effectiveness of the sampling method, and if the samples were taken from the correct locations.

So what allows dogs to detect remnant scent

[stephen25000]

You appear to be talking about organic remains.  I am talking about Cadaver Scent where there are no remains.  If Cadaver Scent had an infinite life then we would all be stinking of it, including the other appartments occupied by the rest of The McCann Friends.

Who said infinite ?

Eleanor, I hate to disappoint you, but cadaver scent is organic.

As i have said before, there are several variables as to what compounds may persist in a given environment and/or on a given material(s).

just remember that dogs olfactory receptors are far more sensitive than our own, and will of course detect the presence of molecules well below the human threshold.

[Mr Gray]

Who said infinite ?

Eleanor, I hate to disappoint you, but cadaver scent is organic.

As i have said before, there are several variables as to what compounds may persist in a given environment and/or on a given material(s).

just remember that dogs olfactory receptors are far more sensitive than our own, and will of course detect the presence of molecules well below the human threshold.

If organic material remains
Is that remnant scent

[carlymichelle]

Who said infinite ?

Eleanor, I hate to disappoint you, but cadaver scent is organic.

As i have said before, there are several variables as to what compounds may persist in a given environment and/or on a given material(s).

just remember that dogs olfactory receptors are far more sensitive than our own, and will of course detect the presence of molecules well below the human threshold.

seems  the dogs get up  supporters noses    dogs can smell  1000s  of times more then humans they can even detect  low blood sugar and  sezuires etc and cancer just by a humans scent

[ShiningInLuz]

That's the whole point
There were no remains in Pdl
You wouldn't get rid of a dinosaur in 2 or 3 washes

LOL.

Enjoyed this!

[Eleanor]

Who said infinite ?

Eleanor, I hate to disappoint you, but cadaver scent is organic.

As i have said before, there are several variables as to what compounds may persist in a given environment and/or on a given material(s).

just remember that dogs olfactory receptors are far more sensitive than our own, and will of course detect the presence of molecules well below the human threshold.

So what did the dogs find?

[Eleanor]

seems  the dogs get up  supporters noses    dogs can smell  1000s  of times more then humans they can even detect  low blood sugar and  sezuires etc and cancer just by a humans scent

Goodness me.  I thought we were discussing Cadaver Scent from no such thing as an actual Cadaver.  Please correct me if I am wrong.

Whoops, I almost missed that you cracked a joke.  Well done you.

[stephen25000]

Goodness me.  I thought we were discussing Cadaver Scent from no such thing as an actual Cadaver.  Please correct me if I am wrong

 'Cadaver Scent from no such thing as an actual Cadaver' ?


and that means precisely what ?

[Eleanor]

'Cadaver Scent from no such thing as an actual Cadaver' ?


and that means precisely what ?

There was no Cadaver.

[stephen25000]

LOL.

Enjoyed this!

Was that tens of millions of years later  ?

Perhaps you would like to see their feathers as well.

[stephen25000]

There was no Cadaver.

Can you cite the evidence for that ?

[stephen25000]

If only they'd develop a cyberdog that sniffed out and barked loudly at forum bullshit, then I'd be happy. 

You don't need a cyberdog for that.

[carlymichelle]

Can you cite the evidence for that ?

eddie and keela told  their handler/police there  was  didnt they?? just because  people  dont  want to accept it doesnt mean  they didnt find any

[Jean-Pierre]

Can you cite the evidence for that ?

Well Stephen. 

Whilst there is a theoretical possibility that there was a cadaver at the scene which nobody noticed, the chance of that happening are quite low.

So for practical purposes I think it is reasonable to assume that there was no cadaver at the time of the searches.

Will that do you?