Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

Nope. It is more logical that SY believe that Madeliene is dead but accept there is a possibility she is alive. There is nothing in their statements that contradict that position.

agree with that, well said
and that's why redwood said there's no clear definitive evidence she is dead IE there was but wasnt definitive aka the dogs and also I assume time lapsed and statistics which police know of


The final report from the cps in PT  said the same, more likely she is dead

tara

[ferryman]

Nope. It is more logical that SY believe that Madeliene is dead but accept there is a possibility she is alive. There is nothing in their statements that contradict that position.

If they accept there is a possibility Madeleine may be alive, then they set absolutely no store by Eddie's alert and intelligence that she may be dead is not, at all, based on Eddie's alerts.

[stephen25000]

If they accept there is a possibility Madeleine may be alive, then they set absolutely no store by Eddie's alert and intelligence that she may be dead is not, at all, based on Eddie's alerts.

Yet Redwood said Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

i.e. They don't have a clue.

[ferryman]

Yet Redwood said Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

i.e. They don't have a clue.

I dismiss any suggestion that thinking is based on Eddie's alerts (or Keela's, come to that).

[stephen25000]

I dismiss any suggestion that thinking is based on Eddie's alerts (or Keela's, come to that).

What value is your opinion on what Redwood said ?

[Mr Gray]

Nope. It is more logical that SY believe that Madeliene is dead but accept there is a possibility she is alive. There is nothing in their statements that contradict that position.

at last you seem to understand...SY accept it is possible that maddie may still be alive...that's what I said in my post......so they do not accept that the dogs alerted to maddie's cadaver

[Mr Gray]

What value is your opinion on what Redwood said ?

as much as your or anyone else's opinion on here

[slartibartfast]

at last you seem to understand...SY accept it is possible that maddie may still be alive...that's what I said in my post......so they do not accept that the dogs alerted to maddie's cadaver

They accept it is possible that the dogs alerted to Madeleine's cadaver.

[stephen25000]

The one question repeatedly evaded is this.

If certain people think Madeleine is still alive, what are the logical possibilities of where she is ?

1. Still with a paedophile(s) ?

2. Living with people aware or unaware of who she is ?

[Mr Gray]

They accept it is possible that the dogs alerted to Madeleine's cadaver.

how do you know that...you are stating your opinion as fact..
my opinion is that they do not accept that..
if the parents are not suspects then there is no time for cadaver odour to develop

[stephen25000]

how do you know that...you are stating your opinion as fact..
my opinion is that they do not accept that..
if the parents are not suspects then there is no time for cadaver odour to develop

A nonsensical argument.

The possibility of her death in the apartment has not been eliminated even by Redwood.

[Mr Gray]

A nonsensical argument.

The possibility of her death in the apartment has not been eliminated even by Redwood.

redwood has said the parents are not suspects...maddie may have died in the apartment at the hands of a stranger but there would be no time for cadaver odour to develop........

[stephen25000]

redwood has said the parents are not suspects...maddie may have died in the apartment at the hands of a stranger but there would be no time for cadaver odour to develop........

If she died in the apartment, you cannot rule out other possibilities.

There is no forensic evidence of an abduction.

[Mr Gray]

If she died in the apartment, you cannot rule out other possibilities.

There is no forensic evidence of an abduction.

I haven't ruled anything out..SY have

[ferryman]

What value is your opinion on what Redwood said ?

When did Redwood say anything about Eddie (or Keela)?