Sceptics beliefs ?

[Erngath]

It will stay AND on a public forum but if the parents can't agree then you have to question if she was in bed.

Do you believe NSY have noted this disagreement in your opinion in the parents testimony?

[Robittybob1]

Do you believe NSY have noted this disagreement in your opinion in the parents testimony?

I don't think there is a real disagreement.  It is like saying the glass is half empty or is it half full.  Maybe she was lying half in and half out.

[Brietta]

I don't think there is a real disagreement.  It is like saying the glass is half empty or is it half full.  Maybe she was lying half in and half out.

It is perfectly possible that Kate and Gerry saw the children at slightly different times when they were leaving the apartment, Gerry looking into the bedroom after Madeleine had had time to push her bedclothes down.

I don't think both parents would be jammed in the bedroom doorway at the same time to allow for the same description.  Far more likely Kate left Madeleine well covered and shortly afterwards gerry saw her as he described.

Damned shoddy 'simulation' what?  closing the shutter left open ... not getting the story straight about how Madeleine was lying in her bed?  Whatever next?

[Lace]

"Madeleine she was in the same position in which he had left her at the beginning of the night." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm

Same position when he later checked. How did Kate see it so differently?

 

SAME POSITION !!!   as in 'sleeping on her side'.

[Lace]

It will stay AND on a public forum but if the parents can't agree then you have to question if she was in bed.

Kate saw Madeleine tucked under the cover,   a while later when Gerry checked she had tossed the cover off.  What's the problem?

[Lace]

Actual evidence vs Peggy invented burglar opening a window and doing a runner

The curtains stayed closed all week in that bedroom and Kate never touched it. How did her fingerprints (only 2 fingers) magically appear on the window behind non-touched curtains? It's not surprising that people don't believe her. The shutters falls back down when raised so how did Kate see them in a fully raised position? They don't even fully raise and the crime scene revealed they were stuck in a nearly closed position. Investigate the crime scene as witnesses will lie if involved.

How did Amaral manage to get the shutters to stay up when he filmed his 'Truth of the Lie'  video?

Kate obviously looked out of the window when she found it open.

[Eleanor]

I was going to say something, but what would be the point with so much nit picking going on?

[barrier]

I was going to say something, but what would be the point with so much nit picking going on?

Well you just did!

"Its hard to dance with the devil on your back"

[Eleanor]

Well you just did!

"Its hard to dance with the devil on your back"

This is true.  But then I don't suppose that you would want to be a Moderator.

[barrier]

How did Amaral manage to get the shutters to stay up when he filmed his 'Truth of the Lie'  video?

Kate obviously looked out of the window when she found it open.

What for,much of a view was it.

[barrier]

This is true.  But then I don't suppose that you would want to be a Moderator.

Been there,seen that,done it.

[Lace]

What for,much of a view was it.

The window was open her child was missing,  wouldn't you look out of the window?

[Eleanor]

Been there,seen that,done it.

So it didn't go well then.

[Angelo222]

The window was open her child was missing,  wouldn't you look out of the window?

She probably opened it herself to look outside, at least that's what the forensics tell us.

[barrier]

So it didn't go well then.

You base that on? strange another mod likes the reply or there again maybe not.